Conecuh County Jury Awards $774,363 to Worker Whose Arm Was Pulled Into Plastic-Netting Machine
After trial: We found no post-trial appeal in public court records. Whether Tenax SPA, an Italian company, has paid the judgment is not public.
Won by Beasley Allen.
John Dees, a staffing-agency worker at a plastic-netting plant in Evergreen, Alabama, had his arm pulled into a Ram4 stretching machine in January 2015. After the Alabama Supreme Court held the Alabama Tenax companies immune under the workers' compensation act, the case went to trial against the Italian manufacturer, Tenax SPA. On Nov. 30, 2018, a Conecuh County jury awarded $649,363 in compensatory damages and $125,000 in punitive damages.
What happened
In January 2015, John Dees was working at the Tenax Manufacturing Alabama plant in Evergreen, where the company makes plastic netting. Dees had been placed at the plant by Onin Staffing. While he was operating a Ram4 stretching machine, his finger caught in the equipment and his arm was drawn in, reportedly up to the shoulder. The injury left permanent disfigurement and a lasting loss of function in the arm.
Dees sued in Conecuh County Circuit Court. His claim was that the Ram4 had design flaws and inadequate safety features that made it dangerous, among them a guard that did not keep a worker's hand from reaching the moving parts and no automatic shut-off. The defendants included Tenax Corporation, Tenax Manufacturing Alabama, Onin Staffing and Tenax SPA, the Italian company that built the machine.
The case stalled first on a question of who could be sued at all. The two Alabama Tenax companies asked the Alabama Supreme Court to order summary judgment in their favor, arguing the exclusive-remedy provisions of the Workers' Compensation Act shielded them from a tort suit. In Ex parte Tenax Corp., decided Jan. 27, 2017, the court granted that petition and ordered summary judgment for the two companies, with Evan G. Allen of the Montgomery firm Beasley, Allen, Crow, Methvin, Portis & Miles appearing for Dees. That ruling took the Alabama companies out of the tort case and left the machine's manufacturer as the defendant.
The case against Tenax SPA was tried in Evergreen, and the jury returned its verdict on Nov. 30, 2018. It awarded Dees $649,363 in compensatory damages and added $125,000 in punitive damages, which Alabama law allows when a jury finds wanton conduct. Together the two awards came to $774,363, against Tenax SPA alone.
The trial presented the machine's guarding as the central failure. Dees's side argued that the guard on the Ram4 fell short of both U.S. and European safety standards, and the punitive award reflects the jury's finding that the manufacturer acted with conscious disregard for the safety of the people who would run the machine.
WorkCompCentral reported the verdict in December 2018 as more than $774,000 for the injured worker. No post-trial appeal turned up in the public court records we searched.
Sources
This account is drawn from contemporaneous public reporting and the court record.
More proven verdicts from Beasley Allen
All Beasley Allen proven verdicts →As chair of the plaintiffs' negotiating committee and Liaison Counsel in the Vioxx multidistrict litigation, Russ Herman directed the negotiations that produced a $4.85 billion settlement with Merck resolving approximately 45,000 to 50,000 personal-injury claims.
Monsanto and its chemical spinoff Solutia agreed in August 2003 to pay $700 million to resolve claims from more than 21,000 Anniston, Alabama residents who were exposed to polychlorinated biphenyls the company manufactured and dumped near their homes for nearly four decades.
San Francisco Unified School District's case was the first JUUL bellwether trial against Altria; after the plaintiffs rested, Altria agreed to pay $235 million to resolve roughly 6,000 pending e-vapor claims nationwide.
Beasley Allen, representing Alabama on contingency, secured $220 million from opioid distributors Cardinal Health and Cencora after roughly 18 months of litigation, with every dollar directed to statewide opioid abatement programs.
Related product liability verdicts
On November 6, 1995, a Mack tractor-trailer hauling logs ran off a Clarke County, Alabama road and rolled over, jamming the passenger door and shifting the logs forward to block the driver's door. The rollover trapped driver Tonnie Ray Witherspoon inside the cab, where a small fire from the crash spread and engulfed the truck, killing him. His mother, Mary Witherspoon, sued Mack Trucks under Alabama's Extended Manufacturer's Liability Doctrine, and a Clarke County jury awarded $50 million in punitive damages, later remitted to $25 million. The Alabama Supreme Court affirmed Mack's liability in 2003 but ordered a further remittitur to $6 million, which Witherspoon accepted.
In 2019 a rented temporary pipe system failed at a Tyson Farms chicken rendering plant in Hanceville, and roughly 220,000 gallons of rendering wastewater went into the Mulberry Fork of the Black Warrior River. Mark Griffin, a boat repairman working on the water downriver in Dora, fell ill and was eventually diagnosed with necrotizing fasciitis.
A Gallatin County jury awarded the widow of Gerald Lutz $815,400 against National Crane Corporation after the 28-year-old groundman was electrocuted when an uninsulated crane cable touched a 7,200-volt power line in 1989. The Montana Supreme Court held the manufacturer's misuse and assumption-of-risk defenses should not have reached the jury. It ordered the jury's 20 percent fault share for Lutz removed and the full verdict reinstated, less a $110,000 settlement credit.
A one-year-old Cleveland girl was doused with Liquid-plumr drain cleaner in 1968 and left with extensive, permanent facial scarring after eleven operations. A federal judge in a bench trial found the manufacturer liable and entered a $1,620,000 judgment for her and her mother. The Sixth Circuit upheld liability on express warranty and set the awards at $665,000 for the child and $27,466 for her mother.