Jury Awards Lincoln Railcar Repairer $9.3 Million After BNSF Crane Accident Left Him With Spine Injuries
After trial: The court cut the judgment only by $37,027.04 in Railroad Retirement Board and sickness benefits that the plaintiff conceded, and refused to remit the jury's valuation. BNSF did not appeal, and a satisfaction of judgment was filed in January 2023.
Won by Chod Law, LLC.
Curt Thege, a BNSF carman at the Havelock Car Shop in Lincoln, was thrown from a scissor lift in June 2019 when an overhead crane hoist moved higher than the operator intended. BNSF admitted it breached its duty of care under the Federal Employers' Liability Act, leaving the jury to decide damages. After a five-day trial the jury returned $9,333,016, and on December 15, 2022 the court entered a $9,295,988.96 judgment after subtracting benefits payments the plaintiff conceded.
What happened
Curt Thege joined BNSF Railway in Lincoln, Nebraska, in June 2006 and spent his whole career repairing damaged railcars at the company's Havelock Car Shop. His supervisor described him in testimony as 'top-notch.' On June 11, 2019, Thege and his partner were stripping damaged side sheet panels from a hopper car, working from scissor lifts while an overhead crane held each panel by chains and hooks.
The crane was supposed to take up slack in the chains and stop. Instead the hoist kept rising. With two small sections of the panel still uncut, the sheet swung out at the bottom and struck Thege's scissor lift, knocking it over. He fell to the floor. The court's summary judgment order describes significant lumbar spine injuries that required several surgeries and left him with permanent impairments.
Jeffrey E. Chod of Chod Law filed the case in the District of Nebraska in February 2020 under the Federal Employers' Liability Act, the statute that lets injured railroad workers sue their employer, and represented Thege through trial. Co-workers testified in discovery that the west bay crane at times kept moving after the operator released the control. BNSF had also abolished its designated crane operator jobs, and the carmen who took over the cranes received far less hands-on training. Shortly before trial BNSF admitted that it breached its duty of care and caused the accident.
That left damages as the contest. Thege's treating physicians included a spine surgeon, a pain specialist, a neurologist, a urologist, a pelvic physical therapist and a neuropsychologist, and BNSF's own expert reviewed a diagnosed brain injury that the company disputed. BNSF also argued Thege could have returned to work earlier than he did. After a five-day trial in October 2022 the jury rejected that argument and awarded $9,333,016: $822,412 for lost earnings, $874,500 for future medical care and supplies, and $7,636,104 in general damages for pain, suffering and disability.
BNSF then asked the court to cut the award. Judge John M. Gerrard refused to second-guess the jury on lost earnings, noting it had weighed the competing evidence and that he found Thege credible when he testified he would have kept working if he could. He found the general damages to be 4.5 times the economic losses, which he called reasonable and, based on his own assessment of the evidence, 'even conservative.' He also found nothing to suggest the jury acted from passion or prejudice.
The one change came from Thege's own concession. He agreed that $37,027.04 in Railroad Retirement Board and supplemental sickness benefits should come off the judgment. In an order dated December 15, 2022, the court granted BNSF's motion only to that extent and entered a separate judgment for $9,295,988.96. BNSF did not appeal, and in January 2023 Chod filed a satisfaction of judgment on Thege's behalf.
Sources
This account is drawn from contemporaneous public reporting and the court record.
- 1.CourtListener, Thege v. BNSF Railway Co., No. 4:20-cv-03014 (D. Neb.), docket
- 2.Thege v. BNSF Railway Co., No. 4:20-cv-3014 (D. Neb.), Order on Rule 59(e) motion, Dec. 15, 2022·Archived copy
- 3.Thege v. BNSF Railway Co., No. 4:20-cv-3014 (D. Neb.), Amended Order on Final Pretrial Conference, Aug. 29, 2022·Archived copy
- 4.Thege v. BNSF Railway Co., No. 4:20-cv-3014 (D. Neb.), Memorandum and Order on summary judgment, May 13, 2022·Archived copy
More proven verdicts from Chod Law, LLC
All Chod Law, LLC proven verdicts →Jimmy Rohr Jr., a BNSF carman, was injured in February 2014 at the Havelock Yard in Lincoln when a railcar wheel rolled over his left foot, leading to 13 surgeries and a below-knee amputation. After a trial in January 2019, a Lancaster County jury valued his damages at $7,112,071 under the Federal Employers' Liability Act and assigned him 51 percent of the fault. After that reduction he was left with about $3,485,000, or 49 percent of the verdict.
Related workplace injury verdicts
The Nebraska Supreme Court reversed a trial court ruling and held that when an employer denies a workers' compensation claim, the employee is not bound by the normal chain-of-referral rules for choosing physicians, and the employer must pay for all medical treatment later found to be compensable.
The Nebraska Supreme Court upheld a permanent total disability award for a truck driver whose 2009 rollover on an Interstate 680 on-ramp in Omaha combined with pre-existing mental and cognitive impairments left him unable to compete in any regular branch of the labor market.
The Nebraska Court of Appeals affirmed a three-judge panel's ruling that Gloria Montoya, a Tyson Foods worker, was permanently and totally disabled as a result of injuries sustained on the job, rejecting the company's appeal in full.
Paul Galland was a deckhand doing repairs aboard an LNG-powered supply vessel at Port Fourchon. LNG vapor had accumulated near a vent on the fly deck. He lit a cigarette and it flashed. He escaped by jumping between decks, breaking his leg on the way down, and suffered severe burns.