$18 millionVerdict

$3.5 Million Settlement After $18 Million Verdict Over Haldol Death of Idaho Nursing Home Resident

Verdict · Benewah County District Court, St. Maries, Idaho · 2006

After trial: The $18 million punitive verdict of May 2006 was replaced by a $3.5 million settlement by November 2006, before any appeal. About $3.4 million came from the home's two insurers and about $100,000 from the home.

Won by Eymann Allison Hunter Jones, P.S..

Delbert Hayward, 86, a mechanic, died in February 1995 after nearly a year at Valley Vista Care Center in St. Maries, Idaho, where his family said he was repeatedly given the antipsychotic drug Haldol to control him. After a three-week trial in May 2006, a Benewah County jury returned an $18 million punitive verdict. By November 2006 the case had resolved in a $3.5 million settlement, most of it paid by the home's insurers.

What happened

Delbert L. Hayward, a mechanic who had been living at home in Emida, Idaho, with help from home health aides, entered Valley Vista Care Center in St. Maries on March 11, 1994. He was 85. He died there on February 16, 1995, at 86. His son, Alfred S. Hayward, sued as personal representative of his estate and spent the next eleven years pursuing the case.

The family's account was that Delbert Hayward was a frail but feisty man who had tried to leave the home and who believed his late wife had been mistreated there. They said staff responded by controlling him with repeated, heavy doses of Haldol, a powerful antipsychotic used here as a chemical restraint, and that the practice contributed to his death. Their lawyers also documented more than 700 violations of federal nursing home regulations in his care.

The case took a long route to trial. Alfred Hayward filed a wrongful-death action in federal court and a contract action in Idaho state court in February 1997. The federal case was dismissed in 1999 for lack of diversity, and the state court declined to add the wrongful-death claim. In 2001 the Idaho Supreme Court reinstated the wrongful-death claim in Hayward v. Valley Vista Care Corp., 136 Idaho 342, while upholding dismissal of the contract claims.

Trial opened in Benewah County in May 2006 and ran three weeks. Spokane lawyer Richard C. Eymann tried the case for the estate, with co-counsel Debra Stephens and Sandra Cody. Dr. Sam Kidder, who helped draft the federal nursing home reform rules governing antipsychotic drugs, testified. On May 17 the jury returned an 11 to 1 verdict of $18 million in punitive damages after less than five hours of deliberation. Eymann said afterward that nursing home abuse would not be tolerated and that he hoped the verdict would change the culture in nursing home care. The home's owner said he planned to appeal.

The verdict did not stand. By early November 2006 the parties had settled for $3.5 million: about $100,000 from Valley Vista and about $3.4 million from its two insurers, Continental and GuideOne Mutual. Court filings showed the case had reached trial in part because those insurers could not agree on a settlement earlier. Eymann said no one wanted to fight Valley Vista in bankruptcy court, adding that you can't get blood out of a turnip. Alfred Hayward said he had made a commitment at his father's grave to try to do something about it.

Sources

This account is drawn from contemporaneous public reporting and the court record.

Related wrongful death verdicts

$5 millionSettlementID

BSR Ventures, doing business as Advanced Heating and Cooling, agreed to a $5 million judgment after its employee, who had seven prior DUI convictions including two felonies, crossed the center line on U.S. 93 and killed Cheryl Miller in a head-on crash.

Hepworth Holzer, LLP2020 · Fourth District Court, Ada County, IdahoRead the full story →
$3.79 millionVerdictID

Krystal Ballard, a 27-year-old Air Force staff sergeant, died of sepsis days after liposuction and a fat transfer at Silk Touch Laser, a medical spa in Eagle, Idaho. After a first trial ended in a mistrial, an Ada County jury in 2014 found the spa and its owner reckless and awarded her husband $3,790,436. The Idaho Supreme Court affirmed the judgment on 4 August 2016, apart from one fee award.

Nevin, Benjamin & McKay LLP2014 · District Court of the Fourth Judicial District, Ada County, IdahoRead the full story →
$3.51 millionVerdictPaidID

A 15-year-old boy died when a Blaine County School District driver-education car was struck during a three-point turn on U.S. Highway 20 near Carey in snow and fog. In 2013 a Blaine County jury found the instructor entirely at fault and reckless, and awarded the boy's parents about $3.51 million. The Idaho Supreme Court affirmed the verdict on 30 March 2015.

Hepworth Law Office2013 · District Court of the Fifth Judicial District, Blaine County, IdahoRead the full story →
$18 millionVerdictReduced from $20 millionTX

A Dallas County jury voted 10-2 in December 2019 that Greyhound Lines was responsible for the 2017 death of 25-year-old Hunter Brown, who was run over by a Greyhound bus at an Oregon rest stop after the driver left early without a head count. The jury awarded his parents $20 million in compensatory damages. It assigned 10 percent of the fault to Brown, so the parents' recovery was $18 million.

Aldous Law2019 · Dallas County District Court, Dallas, TexasRead the full story →