Jury Awards $3.22 Million to Pennsylvania Man and Wife After GEICO Denied Full Underinsured Motorist Benefits
After trial: Jury verdict; capped to $900,000 by policy limits.
Won by Goodrich & Geist, P.C..
A federal jury in Pittsburgh awarded $3.22 million to Ronnie Kirkpatrick and his wife after GEICO refused to pay the full underinsured motorist benefits they were owed following a 2012 crash in Butler County, Pennsylvania.
What happened
On July 6, 2012, Ronnie Kirkpatrick was injured in a car accident in Butler County, Pennsylvania. The other driver was solely at fault. That driver carried only $100,000 in liability coverage, which his insurer paid in full. The problem was that Kirkpatrick's injuries went well beyond $100,000 in damages.
Kirkpatrick and his wife, Michelle Vensel, had purchased underinsured motorist coverage through GEICO Casualty Company with a $900,000 limit specifically to cover a situation like this. They filed a claim seeking compensation for Kirkpatrick's lost earning capacity from their vintage vehicle restoration business, along with pain and suffering, embarrassment and humiliation, loss of enjoyment of life, and Vensel's loss of consortium. GEICO resisted paying full benefits, and the couple filed suit in federal court.
The case went to trial in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania. Joshua P. Geist of Goodrich and Geist, P.C. represented the plaintiffs. GEICO disputed the claimed damages on multiple grounds, arguing that Kirkpatrick's pack-a-week smoking habit should have been admitted into evidence to suggest a health alternative explanation for his condition, and contending that he could not recover lost earning capacity because the vintage car restoration business had operated at a loss before the accident.
The jury rejected GEICO's defenses. It returned a verdict of $3.22 million in total, allocating $2.97 million to Kirkpatrick and $250,000 to Vensel for loss of consortium. Because that award exceeded the $900,000 policy limit, the parties stipulated to mold the judgment down to the coverage cap: $830,160 to Kirkpatrick and $69,840 to Vensel.
GEICO appealed to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, renewing its arguments about the smoking evidence and the pre-accident business losses. On April 22, 2020, a panel of Judges McKee, Ambro, and Phipps affirmed the district court judgment in full. The Third Circuit found no reversible error in the evidentiary rulings and upheld the jury's finding that Kirkpatrick was entitled to recover lost earning capacity from the restoration business despite its prior operating losses.
Sources
This account is drawn from contemporaneous public reporting and the court record.
Related car accident verdicts
On December 7, 2021, a Nueces County jury in Corpus Christi returned $1.04 billion in actual damages and $300 billion in exemplary damages, about $301.04 billion in total, against Beer Belly's Sports Bar and its owner for overserving a driver who killed Tamra Kay Kindred, 59, and her 16-year-old granddaughter in a 2017 crash. It was reported as the largest jury verdict ever recorded, and it was built to be symbolic: the bar had closed in 2019, Texas does not require bars to carry liquor liability insurance, and the family and its lawyers said openly that they expected to recover nothing and sought the number as a public statement against drunk driving. John Flood of Flood Trial Lawyers was lead counsel, with Sico, Hoelscher & Harris LLP as co-counsel; Craig Sico delivered the closing argument that asked jurors to decide how loudly their voice would be heard.
An Oakland County jury awarded $896.5 million to a young boy who was struck by a prototype test car during a student field trip at a Continental test track, reported as the largest verdict in Michigan history. The award is pre-appeal: post-trial motions are pending, Continental never made a settlement offer, and the amount could still be reduced.
A Bexar County jury awarded roughly $831 million to Blas Mendez Jr., a longtime Seguin ISD special education behavior specialist left partially paralyzed after his motorcycle hit wreckage left in the road by an 18-year-old drunk driver who had been served at Koozies Icehouse & Grill in New Braunfels. Todd A. Hunter of Hunter Trial Law tried the dram shop case with E. Chevo Pastrano and Ginna G. Pastrano of The Pastrano Law Firm. The award was reported as the largest verdict ever returned by a San Antonio jury, and the bar had already closed by the time it came in, so the family is not expected to collect most, if any, of it.
A Harris County jury awarded Mary Johnson $557 million against Union Pacific for a 2016 Houston train strike that cost her a leg, several fingers, and left her with a brain injury, a figure the trial court later cut and an appeals court reversed for a new trial.