$1.66M Jury Verdict for Commercial Tenant Left with Permanent Brain Damage After Stairway Fall
Won by Hepworth Holzer, LLP.
A Boise jury awarded more than $1.66 million to a commercial tenant who suffered permanent brain damage after falling on improperly installed stairs, a verdict affirmed on appeal by the Idaho Supreme Court.
What happened
On March 20, 2006, James Phillips was descending an exterior stairway at a commercial property in Ada County, Idaho, carrying a box of trash to dispose of it. He fell while on the lower flight of steps and was found face-down on the concrete landing at the bottom. The cause became clear during investigation: the landlords, Milt and Mary Erhart, had installed concrete stairs with two treads bolted on only one side, leaving the structure unstable.
Phillips sustained a closed head injury that caused permanent brain damage and lasting memory loss, along with other physical injuries. His wife, Gale Phillips, suffered the loss of her husband's companionship and support. The injuries altered both of their lives permanently.
Kurt Holzer of Holzer Edwards, Chtd. (now Hepworth Holzer, LLP) represented the Phillips family at trial. Holzer argued that the landlords' faulty installation of the stairs constituted willful and reckless conduct, a finding the jury ultimately accepted. The trial in the Fourth District Court took place in April 2009.
The jury awarded James Phillips $546,174 in economic damages and $562,000 in noneconomic damages, and awarded Gale Phillips $556,200 in noneconomic damages for loss of consortium, bringing the total verdict to $1,664,374. The district court subsequently granted a remittitur, ordering a new trial unless the plaintiffs accepted a reduction in economic damages to $253,014.49. The Phillipses accepted the reduction, and the court entered judgment accordingly.
The Erharts appealed. The Idaho Supreme Court affirmed in 2011, holding that sufficient evidence supported both the causation findings and the jury's determination that the landlords had acted in a willful and reckless manner. The reported citation is Phillips v. Erhart, 151 Idaho 100, 254 P.3d 1 (Idaho 2011).
Sources
This account is drawn from contemporaneous public reporting and the court record.
More proven verdicts from Hepworth Holzer, LLP
All Hepworth Holzer, LLP proven verdicts →BSR Ventures, doing business as Advanced Heating and Cooling, agreed to a $5 million judgment after its employee, who had seven prior DUI convictions including two felonies, crossed the center line on U.S. 93 and killed Cheryl Miller in a head-on crash.
A federal jury awarded Kevin Marchand $4.2 million after emergency room physicians at Mercy Medical Center removed his cervical collar following an industrial accident, missing a cervical spine fracture that left him permanently paralyzed.
A passenger was seriously hurt when the driver left an Idaho road at high speed and rolled the car two or three times. The driver conceded sole liability, and the district court, sitting without a jury, found five broken ribs and permanent compression fractures at five levels of the thoracic spine. It entered judgment for $165,228.84, and the Idaho Supreme Court affirmed in 1990.
Related slip & fall verdicts
A Cook County jury awarded $32 million to truck driver Stephanie Johnson, who developed Complex Regional Pain Syndrome after slipping on oil at an ExxonMobil facility, in what the Jury Verdict Reporter recorded as the largest CRPS verdict in Illinois history.
After a neurosurgeon slipped on a wet hospital pantry floor and developed reflex sympathetic dystrophy that ended his surgical career, an Evansville jury found St. Mary's Medical Center fully at fault and awarded $16.95 million, a verdict the Indiana Court of Appeals later affirmed.
A Kern County jury awarded William Kidd and his wife Elaine $16.2 million after he slipped at a Bakersfield El Pollo Loco and suffered a brain injury that later required surgery.
A Clark County jury held Lowe's responsible after Kelly Hendrickson slipped on liquid draining from store planters, fractured her skull, and permanently lost her senses of taste and smell.