$2.5 millionVerdictReduced from $4.0 million

Log Truck Driver Hurt by Falling Logs at Smurfit-Stone Mill Wins $3.97 Million

Verdict · Missoula County District Court, Montana · 2014

After trial: Affirmed by the Montana Supreme Court in 2015 MT 81, but a 2012 bankruptcy stipulation capped the Ginns' recovery at $2.5 million, so the $3.97 million judgment could not be collected in full. Smurfit set aside cash and stock toward any judgment, but no source we found says what was paid.

Won by Hoyt & Blewett PLLC.

Allen Ginn, a log truck driver, was injured in July 2008 when logs fell on him at a Smurfit-Stone mill near Missoula. Smurfit-Stone defaulted on liability, and a Missoula County jury set damages at $3,470,899.56 for Ginn and $500,000 for his wife Laurie. The Montana Supreme Court affirmed in 2015, but a bankruptcy stipulation the Ginns had to accept to bring the suit capped their recovery at $2.5 million.

What happened

On July 11, 2008, Allen Ginn, a 49-year-old log truck driver employed by Ginn Trucking, hauled a load of logs to a mill owned by Smurfit-Stone Container in Missoula County, Montana. After he arrived and released the load, several logs fell on him. He was hurt badly: skull fractures and bleeding around the brain, fractures in the lower spine, and breaks to his right hip and pelvis. He was in a coma for several days. The lasting effects include a brain injury, occasional seizures, memory loss and chronic fatigue.

The Ginns' case was that the mill had no safe way to unload. Their lawyers argued that the company did not provide an operable rack to hold the logs in place and used an unloading procedure that was dangerous because the load was not secured first.

Smurfit-Stone was in Chapter 11 bankruptcy in Delaware, which shaped how the case could be brought. After the Ginns asked the bankruptcy court for permission to pursue their claim, the two sides negotiated a stipulation that the court approved on June 28, 2012. It let the Ginns sue in Montana state court and required Smurfit to set aside cash and Rock-Tenn stock to satisfy any settlement or judgment. The price was a limit on what the Ginns could recover: according to their appellate brief, the stipulation capped their damages at $2.5 million.

The Ginns filed suit in Missoula County and mailed the complaint to the company lawyer the stipulation named to accept service. When no answer came, they served the papers again by hand at Rock-Tenn's front desk. Smurfit still did not respond, and the court entered default on liability on September 27, 2012. Smurfit appeared only after that, and the District Court refused to undo the default, finding it willful.

That left causation and damages for a jury. Smurfit argued that an earlier tractor-trailer crash, not the mill accident, accounted for Ginn's disability, and its medical expert testified that the brain injury was mild. After a four-day trial before Judge John W. Larson, the court entered judgment on January 21, 2014. The jury awarded Allen Ginn $3,470,899.56 and his wife, Laurie Ginn, $500,000 for loss of consortium, for a total of $3,970,899.56. Because of the bankruptcy stipulation, the most the Ginns could recover on that judgment was $2.5 million.

Smurfit appealed, arguing the default should have been set aside. On March 17, 2015, the Montana Supreme Court affirmed in Ginn v. Smurfit Stone Container Enterprises, 2015 MT 81. Justice Michael Wheat's opinion held that Smurfit had ignored service in a manner it had itself negotiated, and that the Ginns would be prejudiced by further delay after years without Ginn's income, since they remained bound by the liability cap they had bargained away. The court declined to reach Smurfit's constitutional arguments because they had not been raised in the District Court. Alexander (Zander) Blewett III and Kurt M. Jackson of Hoyt & Blewett PLLC in Great Falls represented the Ginns, and the court's docket shows the case closed on remittitur on April 2, 2015.

Sources

This account is drawn from contemporaneous public reporting and the court record.

More proven verdicts from Hoyt & Blewett PLLC

All Hoyt & Blewett PLLC proven verdicts →
$26 millionSettlementCar AccidentsMT

Jeremy Vangsnes, a 21-year-old cross-country athlete who was left quadriplegic and brain-injured after a 2009 rollover on Interstate 90 near Belgrade, Montana, settled for $26 million against the North American Mission Board of the Southern Baptist Convention after a judge ruled the driver was acting within the scope of his agency with the organization.

2015 · Gallatin County District Court, Montana (Judge Mike Salvagni)Read the full story →
$2.5 millionVerdictGroup recoveryWrongful DeathMT

A Butte federal jury returned a $2.5 million verdict for the families of two women killed when a Patrol Helicopters fuel-truck driver failed to signal before turning on a Park County road, and the Ninth Circuit unanimously affirmed the award.

2008 · U.S. District Court, District of Montana (Butte); affirmed 9th CircuitRead the full story →
$969,797VerdictWorkplace InjuryMT

The Montana Supreme Court reversed a 50% contributory-negligence deduction and restored the full $969,797 jury verdict for the widow of welding supervisor Andre Woods, who was killed when a hy-rail vehicle traveled more than four miles past its authorized track warrant limits and collided with an oncoming train.

2004 · Montana Supreme Court (2004 MT 301)Read the full story →

Related workplace injury verdicts

$1.7 millionVerdictPaidMT

Robert Dannels, a BNSF railroad trackman, suffered a permanently disabling back and spine injury in 2010 when a skid-steer loader he was operating struck a buried steel wellhead. A Cascade County jury in 2013 found BNSF 100 percent at fault and awarded $1.7 million under the Federal Employers' Liability Act. The court denied BNSF's motion for a new trial, and BNSF paid the full verdict amount.

Conner, Marr & Pinski PLLP2013 · Cascade County District Court (Eighth Judicial District), Great Falls, MontanaRead the full story →
$6.9 millionSettlementMT

John Amsden served as co-lead counsel for hospital employees whose employers secretly accepted $26 million from Blue Cross Blue Shield of Montana in exchange for six years of exclusive coverage, inflating the workers' health-plan premiums.

Beck Amsden & Stalpes2019 · U.S. District Court, District of Montana (Great Falls)Read the full story →
$36.5 millionVerdictMT

Ralph Hutt worked 18 months at W.R. Grace's asbestos-contaminated vermiculite mill in Libby, Montana in the late 1960s and developed asbestosis decades later. A Cascade County jury found the mill's workers' compensation insurer, Maryland Casualty Company, breached an independent duty to warn him about hazards it tracked through undisclosed chest X-rays, and awarded $36.5 million in February 2022. The trial judge completed Montana's mandatory review of the punitive portion in January 2023 and declined to reduce it, calling the insurer's conduct reprehensible. Maryland Casualty appealed, but the appeal ended in a confidential settlement in 2024, so the verdict itself, not any later court reduction, is what stood.

Edwards & Culver2022 · Montana Asbestos Claims Court (Cascade County District Court, Great Falls)Read the full story →
$2.47 millionSettlementNY

A 43-year-old construction worker suffered nerve damage and two lumbar surgeries after his drill struck a live conduit in a parking garage where his foreman had assured the crew the power was off.

The Orlow Firm2023Read the full story →