$13.5 millionVerdict

Philadelphia Jury Awards $13.5 Million Against Ethicon Over TVT Sling That Eroded and Needed Removal

Verdict · Philadelphia County Court of Common Pleas, PA · 2016

After trial: The Pennsylvania Superior Court affirmed the judgment on all issues on April 11, 2019, including the punitive damages and about $238,000 in delay damages added after trial. We did not confirm whether Ethicon sought further review or whether the judgment was paid.

Won by Kline & Specter, PC.

A Philadelphia jury found Ethicon's TVT sling, implanted during Sharon Carlino's 2005 hysterectomy, defective in design and warnings. The mesh twice pushed through her vaginal wall, and she needed corrective surgeries in 2007 and 2010 before her pain returned in 2012. The jury awarded $3.5 million in compensatory damages, including $250,000 to her husband for loss of consortium, and $10 million in punitive damages, and the Pennsylvania Superior Court affirmed.

What happened

A Philadelphia jury returned a $13.5 million verdict on February 10, 2016, against Ethicon, Inc. and its parent Johnson & Johnson. The case was brought by Sharon Carlino, a New Jersey woman, and her husband Charles over the company's TVT transvaginal sling, a mesh tape sold to treat stress urinary incontinence.

On August 18, 2005, Carlino's surgeon implanted the TVT during a laparoscopic hysterectomy. The hysterectomy relieved the back pain caused by uterine fibroids, and for a time the sling seemed to work. In 2007 she felt something sharp in her vagina. Part of the mesh had become exposed, and she had corrective surgery that November. In 2010 the sharp pain came back, along with pain during sex, and a urogynecologist found a second exposure and removed part of the sling that December. Her pain returned in late 2012. An expert who examined her before trial found the mesh left on one side had contracted into a band that could be felt through the vaginal wall, and said a further surgery could not remove all of it.

The trial turned on what Ethicon knew and told patients. The plaintiffs argued the sling was defectively designed and that its instructions and patient brochures left out known risks. Testimony from Ethicon's own medical directors, including Piet Hinoul, Martin Weisberg and David Robinson, acknowledged complications such as erosion, chronic pain, painful intercourse and the possible need for repeat surgery. Robinson, a former medical director, testified that the risk of erosion lasts as long as the mesh stays in the body. The plaintiffs said none of that appeared in the warnings Ethicon gave patients. Ethicon answered that the TVT was properly designed and labeled and that it was not the cause of her continuing medical problems.

Shanin Specter of Kline & Specter tried the case for the Carlinos, and Charles L. Becker later argued for them on appeal. The jury found the TVT defective in design and in its warnings, and found Ethicon's conduct willful and wanton. It awarded $3.25 million to Sharon Carlino for her injuries and $250,000 to Charles Carlino for loss of consortium, a combined $3.5 million in compensatory damages, plus $10 million in punitive damages. It was the second pelvic mesh case to reach a verdict in Philadelphia, two months after a jury there returned an award against Ethicon in the first.

After trial the court denied Ethicon's post-trial motions and added $238,119 in delay damages. On appeal Ethicon argued that Pennsylvania courts lacked jurisdiction over it, that the 2013 lawsuit came too late, that the trial court wrongly excluded evidence about the FDA's clearance of the device, and that the compensatory and punitive awards could not stand. The Pennsylvania Superior Court rejected each argument in an opinion filed April 11, 2019. On the deadline, it noted conflicting evidence over whether her doctors had blamed her 2007 and 2010 problems on the mesh or on the surgery itself, so the question belonged to the jury, which found she could not reasonably have known the cause before June 2011. She had connected her symptoms to mesh products after seeing a television advertisement in April 2013.

Sources

This account is drawn from contemporaneous public reporting and the court record.

More proven verdicts from Kline & Specter, PC

All Kline & Specter, PC proven verdicts →
$4.85 billionSettlementGroup recoveryProduct LiabilityLA

As chair of the plaintiffs' negotiating committee and Liaison Counsel in the Vioxx multidistrict litigation, Russ Herman directed the negotiations that produced a $4.85 billion settlement with Merck resolving approximately 45,000 to 50,000 personal-injury claims.

2007 · U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Louisiana (MDL-1657)Read the full story →
$400 millionVerdictOn appealProduct LiabilityPA

A Philadelphia jury found that Monsanto failed to warn that Roundup could cause cancer and awarded John McKivison $2.25 billion. The trial judge later reduced the award to $400 million.

2024 · Philadelphia County, PARead the full story →
$265 millionSettlementGroup recoveryWrongful DeathPA

After Amtrak Train 188 derailed in Philadelphia in May 2015, killing eight and injuring more than 200, Kline & Specter's Thomas R. Kline led the plaintiffs' negotiations that produced a $265 million settlement fund for the victims.

2016 · Philadelphia, PA (federal)Read the full story →
$207.6 millionVerdictMedical MalpracticePA

A Philadelphia jury found the Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania liable for the brain injury a newborn suffered when staff delayed a cesarean section, a $182.7 million verdict that grew to a molded judgment of about $207.6 million, the largest medical malpractice award in Pennsylvania history. Kline & Specter argued and won the appeal, where the Pennsylvania Superior Court affirmed the full $207.6 million judgment in July 2025.

2025 · Philadelphia County, PARead the full story →

Related product liability verdicts

$17.34 millionPA

Leroy Rice, a forklift operator, was left permanently paralyzed on September 18, 2001, when a storage racking system at his Philadelphia warehouse job collapsed and dropped roughly a ton of frozen food on him. A Philadelphia jury awarded him $12,400,000 at a second trial in 2010, after the Superior Court reversed the first trial's judgment and ordered a new trial on damages, and the trial court molded that verdict to $17,339,797.30 to add delay damages. The Pennsylvania Superior Court affirmed the judgment against racking manufacturer Interlake Material Handling Inc. on February 22, 2012, according to contemporaneous legal-press coverage. Thomas J. Duffy Jr. is named in the trial court's opinion as counsel for Rice.

The Duffy Firm2012 · Pennsylvania Superior Court, on appeal from Philadelphia County Court of Common PleasRead the full story →
$34 millionVerdictPA

A Philadelphia jury awarded Donna Kendall $6.3 million in compensatory damages and $28 million in punitive damages after finding that Wyeth's Prempro hormone-replacement drug caused her breast cancer and the double mastectomy that followed; the Pennsylvania Superior Court restored the full punitive award in 2012 after the trial judge had cut it to $1 million.

Jacoby & Meyers, LLP2009 · Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas, PARead the full story →
$46 millionSettlementPA

Alan Feldman of Feldman Shepherd secured a $46 million settlement against IKEA on behalf of the family of a 2-year-old boy crushed by a MALM dresser in California, reported at the time as the largest child wrongful-death settlement in U.S. history.

Feldman Shepherd Wohlgelernter Tanner Weinstock Dodig2020 · Private mediationRead the full story →
$50 millionSettlementGroup recoveryPA

Feldman Shepherd secured a combined $50 million settlement from IKEA on behalf of three families whose toddler sons were fatally crushed by MALM dressers, a result that preceded a nationwide recall of approximately 29 million chests and dressers.

Feldman Shepherd Wohlgelernter Tanner Weinstock Dodig2016 · Private mediation (JAMS)Read the full story →