Confidential Settlement with Allsup's After Jury Signals $51M Award for Slain Hobbs Clerk
A confidential settlement ended a wrongful-death trial against Allsup's Enterprises after a Santa Fe jury, deliberating on a $51 million award, was told the case had resolved.
What happened
Elizabeth Garcia was 26 years old and four days into her job when she vanished from an Allsup's convenience store in Hobbs, New Mexico, during a solo overnight shift on January 16, 2002. Her body was found the same day in a nearby field. A medical examination revealed 57 stab wounds. Paul Lovett was later arrested, convicted of first-degree murder, and sentenced to life in prison.
Garcia's three young children brought a civil wrongful-death action against Allsup's Enterprises of Clovis, the largest convenience store chain in New Mexico. The lawsuit, filed in Santa Fe state district court in 2005, alleged that Allsup's failed to install video surveillance cameras at the store and refused to require a second employee during late-night shifts, despite documented crime problems at that location. According to allegations in the filing, Hobbs police had identified the store as 'a large component of the total crime occurring in Hobbs,' and the police chief had previously met with an Allsup's vice president to discuss the issue. Lovett himself later told investigators he had targeted the store partly because he noticed no cameras and no other staff.
At trial, lead counsel Randi McGinn asked the jury to award $60 million. Allsup's defense counsel argued for $3 million. After two days of deliberations, the jury reached a figure: forewoman Jean Lehman confirmed afterward that jurors had settled on $21.2 million in compensatory damages and $30 million in punitive damages, a total of $51.2 million. Judge Raymond Ortiz interrupted the proceedings before the verdict was formally returned.
Minutes before the jury was brought in to deliver its award, the parties reached a confidential settlement. The terms were not disclosed. In a letter to jurors after the resolution, Garcia's family and legal team stated that Allsup's had committed to never challenge New Mexico's convenience store safety regulations. The case directly contributed to state rules requiring stores open after 11 p.m. to either employ two clerks, install bulletproof barriers limiting customer access, or close.
A. Elicia Montoya was co-counsel with McGinn on the matter.
Sources
This account is drawn from contemporaneous public reporting and the court record.
- 1.ABC7 Amarillo - Allsup's clerk death lawsuit reaches settlement (Apr 2008)·Archived copy
- 2.ABC7 Amarillo - Family seeks millions in clerk's slaying (Apr 2008)·Archived copy
- 3.Security Info Watch (Associated Press) - Estate of clerk sues convenience store chain over lack of security·Archived copy
- 4.Eastern New Mexico News - Settlement reached in lawsuit over death of Allsup's clerk (Apr 9, 2008)
- 5.Santa Fe New Mexican - Allsup's settles with family of slain clerk·Archived copy
More proven verdicts from McGinn Montoya Love Curry & Sievers
All McGinn Montoya Love Curry & Sievers proven verdicts →A New Mexico jury found German device maker Biotronik and its sales representative liable for conspiring with a Las Cruces cardiologist and a hospital to implant medically unnecessary pacemakers in dozens of patients for profit.
A New Mexico jury found Utility Trailer Manufacturing negligent for failing to install side underride guards, awarding the family of a 16-year-old killed in a 2015 highway fire crash a net verdict of $18.9 million.
A federal judge awarded $10.55 million to the family of Esther Nakajjigo, a 25-year-old Ugandan human rights activist killed on her honeymoon when an unsecured metal gate arm at Arches National Park swung into her husband's vehicle, delivering the largest federal wrongful death verdict in Utah history.
An Albuquerque jury awarded $7.75 million to Michael Webb and his wife after Presbyterian Hospital ICU staff failed to reposition him for extended stretches, causing a devastating Stage 4 pressure ulcer that remained unhealed more than five years later.
Related wrongful death verdicts
In December 2011, a Fayette County, Texas jury awarded the family of an 8-year-old Splendora boy $150.37 billion after he was doused with gasoline and set on fire by a 13-year-old neighbor in 1998, two weeks after the same neighbor sexually assaulted him. The boy survived third-degree burns over 99 percent of his body for nearly 13 years before dying in April 2011 of a skin cancer linked to his injuries. The defendant, Don Wilburn Collins, never appeared to answer the civil suit, and the jury awarded $370 million in actual damages plus roughly $150 billion in punitive damages, the largest civil verdict in U.S. history. Attorney Craig Sico, who represented the family, said from the outset that the judgment was not collectible and was intended to pressure prosecutors into reopening the long-dormant criminal case. Prosecutors did reopen the case, and Collins was later convicted of capital murder in a separate criminal proceeding.
A Pensacola jury awarded Cynthia Robinson $23.6 billion in punitive damages against R.J. Reynolds over the 1996 lung cancer death of her 36-year-old husband, the largest single-plaintiff award of Florida's Engle tobacco litigation, but the trial judge called the number constitutionally excessive, an appeals court ordered a full retrial over improper closing arguments, and a second jury returned a complete defense verdict in 2019, so the estate ultimately collected nothing.
Frantz Law Group, representing roughly 5,000 victims, helped negotiate a $13.5 billion PG&E bankruptcy settlement covering tens of thousands of survivors and families from the 2015 Butte, 2017 North Bay, and 2018 Camp wildfires.