$13 millionVerdict

Sussex County Jury Awards $13 Million After Alzheimer's Patient Is Found Locked in Nursing Home Freezer

Verdict · Delaware Superior Court, Sussex County · 2005

After trial: The Delaware Supreme Court affirmed the verdict in 2006 and the trial court had denied a new trial or remittitur. The punitive damages claim was settled during trial for an amount that was not reported.

Won by Murphy & Landon, P.A..

Julie Bailey, a 60-year-old woman with Alzheimer's disease, was found locked in the kitchen freezer room of the Lewes Convalescent Center hours after she was admitted in December 2002, and she died on January 21, 2003. A Sussex County jury awarded $13 million in compensatory damages to her estate, her husband and her three sons in March 2005. The Delaware Supreme Court affirmed the judgment in 2006.

What happened

On December 28, 2002, Julie Bailey, who was 60 and had Alzheimer's disease, arrived at the Lewes Convalescent Center in Lewes, Delaware, at about 11:00 a.m. Her disease had left her functioning at the intellectual level of a two-year-old. She had been in the facility's care for roughly four to five hours when staff discovered that she was missing from her room.

The staff searched the building and the surrounding area for about four and a half hours. They then found her locked inside a freezer room in the kitchen. According to the Delaware Supreme Court's account of the trial record, she was frozen to the floor of the freezer by her own urine. She had frostbite on her hands, feet and nose.

The treatment for those injuries added to her suffering. The record showed that she was not given pain medication before her frostbite treatments. Julie Bailey developed a pulmonary embolism and died on January 21, 2003, a little more than three weeks after she was admitted.

Her husband, Anthony Bailey, who served as administrator of her estate, and her three sons sued Lewes Convalescent Center and Beebe Medical Center in Delaware Superior Court, Sussex County, under Delaware's medical negligence and wrongful death laws. The case went to a jury from March 9 to March 16, 2005. Chase T. Brockstedt, then with Murphy Spadaro & Landon (now Murphy & Landon), appeared for the family on appeal, according to the Supreme Court's counsel listing.

The jury returned compensatory verdicts totaling $13 million: $4 million to Julie Bailey's estate, $3 million to her husband, and $2 million to each of her three sons. The family's claim for punitive damages was settled on March 15, 2005, while the trial was under way. The amount of that settlement has not been reported.

The defendants moved for a new trial or a reduced award, and the trial judge denied the motion. They appealed, challenging the refusal to separate the damages claims for trial, the decision to let family members recover for their own emotional distress, and a jury instruction. In 2006, the Delaware Supreme Court rejected all three arguments and affirmed the judgment in Beebe Medical Center, Inc. v. Bailey, 913 A.2d 543.

Sources

This account is drawn from contemporaneous public reporting and the court record.

Related wrongful death verdicts

$7.55 millionSettlementGroup recoveryPaidDE

Delaware agreed in December 2017 to pay $7.55 million to settle a federal suit over the February 2017 uprising at the James T. Vaughn Correctional Center in Smyrna, where Lt. Steven Floyd was killed and other officers were held hostage. The plaintiffs said years of understaffing and forced overtime left the prison exposed. The money was divided among 11 claimants and the split was not made public, so the figure is an aggregate. The state denied wrongdoing.

Jacobs & Crumplar2017 · U.S. District Court for the District of Delaware, WilmingtonRead the full story →
$1.37 millionVerdictReduced from $1.7 millionDE

In April 2018, a nine-year-old girl was struck and killed by a passing car after crossing German Road in Seaford, Delaware, to check the mail. The driver, Dwayne McConnell, admitted he was inattentive and fled the scene; the girl had been in the care of her mother's boyfriend, Bryan Winder, while her mother was at work. A Sussex County jury found the girl was not negligent, split fault 90 percent to McConnell and 10 percent to Winder, and returned a verdict of $1,718,069.44 for her mother and her estate. The trial judge later set aside $350,000 of that award for the estate's conscious pain and suffering claim, leaving a judgment of $1,368,069.44 plus interest. Winder's first attempt to appeal was dismissed as premature in January 2026, without prejudice to a new appeal once a final judgment is entered.

Shelsby & Leoni, P.A.2025 · Delaware Superior Court, Sussex CountyRead the full story →
$13 millionVerdictOn appealTX

Charles Payne Sr., 75, died after an HPD patrol car driven by Officer Christopher Cabrera struck his vehicle on North Shepherd Drive in Houston on December 26, 2021. A federal jury found in November 2025 that the City of Houston was deliberately indifferent in adopting an inadequate policy that let officers drive recklessly. It awarded $13 million to his family. The city's new-trial motion was denied and its appeal to the Fifth Circuit is pending.

Ben Crump Law2025 · U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Texas, HoustonRead the full story →
$13 millionVerdictGroup recoveryCA

After a 99-day bench trial, San Diego Superior Court Judge Kevin A. Enright awarded approximately $12.775 million in compensatory and punitive damages to 22 women who were deceived into appearing in online pornographic videos produced by GirlsDoPorn, with the court also ordering payment of $8 million in attorneys' fees.

Thorsnes Bartolotta McGuire2020 · San Diego Superior CourtRead the full story →