$4.7 Million Affirmed for Motorcycle Passenger Thrown Into Elevated-Train Pillar on Westchester Avenue
After trial: Affirmed on appeal.
Won by Rosenberg, Minc, Falkoff & Wolff.
A Bronx jury awarded motorcycle passenger Jose Cabrera $5.1 million after a New York City Transit Authority bus driver merged into his lane and forced the bike into a concrete pillar; the First Department affirmed the liability verdict and pain-and-suffering awards while reducing future medical expenses, bringing the final judgment to $4.7 million.
What happened
On May 31, 2013, Jose Cabrera was riding as a passenger on a motorcycle traveling along Westchester Avenue near 156th Street in the Bronx when a New York City Transit Authority bus accelerated from behind and merged into the motorcycle's lane. The impact forced the bike into one of the concrete columns supporting the elevated train tracks above the roadway.
The collision left Cabrera with a comminuted, displaced acetabulum fracture requiring open surgery, a comminuted pelvis fracture, a femur dislocation, a mid-shaft ulna fracture that also required open reduction and internal fixation, and fractures to the scapula and five ribs. He spent six months confined to a wheelchair and was placed on narcotic pain medication that he continued to rely on well after the initial recovery period.
Daniel C. Minc of Rosenberg, Minc, Falkoff and Wolff tried the case in Bronx County Supreme Court. The jury found the bus driver negligent and apportioned 30 percent of the fault to the Transit Authority defendants. On damages, the jury returned $1.5 million for past pain and suffering and $3 million for future pain and suffering over ten years, plus $600,000 for projected future medical costs.
The New York City Transit Authority appealed. The Appellate Division, First Department, affirmed the negligence finding and both pain-and-suffering awards in full. The court did find the $600,000 future medical award speculative and reduced it to $200,000, bringing the total affirmed judgment to $4.7 million. The Transit Authority's remaining challenges to the verdict were rejected.
Sources
This account is drawn from contemporaneous public reporting and the court record.
More proven verdicts from Rosenberg, Minc, Falkoff & Wolff
All Rosenberg, Minc, Falkoff & Wolff proven verdicts →Howard Menifield, 44, tripped in a hole in the paved courtyard of his Bronx apartment building in May 2011 and fractured and dislocated his right ankle. After a three-week trial in March 2018, a Bronx jury found the building's owners liable and assessed damages at $2,375,000. A high/low agreement made before the verdict set the recovery at $775,000, which Menifield received.
Related motorcycle accident verdicts
A Waterbury jury awarded Don Zemo IV $45 million after finding that a tow truck illegally parked outside MyHoopty.com's Oakville lot blocked the sightline for a car pulling out, causing a collision that left him permanently paralyzed.
A Pierce County jury awarded $44.7 million to an EMT and volunteer firefighter left with permanent injuries after an SUV driver turned left through an uncontrolled intersection and into his path, a verdict Washington courts later upheld in full.
Shannon Shaw was riding his motorcycle in St. George, South Carolina, in September 2021 when an Amazon delivery van turned left across his path. He suffered a traumatic brain injury and orthopedic injuries that led to a cervical fusion. In December 2023 a Dorchester County jury found Amazon vicariously liable and grossly negligent and returned $44.63 million, including $30 million in punitive damages against Amazon.
A Marion County jury in March 2024 awarded $60.7 million to motorcyclist Christopher Dugan after a Tesla service manager crossed double yellow lines and struck him, leaving him with a permanent traumatic brain injury and a partial foot amputation; comparative fault reduced the net award to $42.5 million.