Judge Adds $4.2 Million in Sanctions After BNSF Destroys Evidence in Four-Death Crossing Crash
After trial: Sanctions award.
Won by Schwebel, Goetz & Sieben, P.A..
Following a $24 million wrongful-death jury verdict, Anoka County District Court Judge Ellen Maas imposed more than $4.2 million in additional sanctions against BNSF Railway for destroying evidence, fabricating records, and obstructing the investigation of a crash that killed four young people.
What happened
Shortly after 10 p.m. on September 26, 2003, a westbound BNSF freight train struck a car at the Ferry Street grade crossing in Anoka, Minnesota. All four occupants died: Brian Frazier, 20; Corey Chase, 20; Harry Rhoades Jr., 19; and Bridgette Shannon, 17. BNSF quickly blamed the driver, claiming the car had driven around activated warning gates to beat the train.
The families hired separate attorneys who coordinated their cases. Paul Godlewski of Schwebel, Goetz and Sieben represented the Chase family. Co-counsel Robert Pottroff, Sharon Van Dyck, and William Bongard represented the other three families. Together they argued BNSF had failed to maintain the crossing's signals and lights, and that at least three prior collisions at the same location had gone unaddressed.
The six-week liability and damages trial concluded in summer 2008. The jury found BNSF 90 percent causally negligent and the driver 10 percent at fault. It awarded $6 million to each family, a total of $24 million, which Minnesota Lawyer reported was the largest known wrongful-death verdict in state history for families of emancipated, unmarried adult children.
Judge Ellen Maas then took up BNSF's conduct during litigation. She found what she described as a pattern of misconduct beginning within minutes of the crash: the railroad lost a laptop containing locomotive event-recorder data and later produced a device with altered data; employees gave misleading depositions and affidavits; and company witnesses obstructed law-enforcement access to the accident site. The judge wrote that BNSF engaged in a "systematic exploitation of the civil-justice system of a pervasiveness seldom seen outside of John Grisham novels." In early 2009, she imposed $4,180,398.90 in sanctions, comprising attorney fees, litigation costs, and percentages of the liability award.
BNSF appealed. In September 2010, the Minnesota Court of Appeals affirmed the sanctions award but ordered a new liability trial, finding that the jury had received instructions on common-law negligence rather than the federal standard of care required by the Federal Railroad Safety Act. On March 28, 2012, the Minnesota Supreme Court reversed the Court of Appeals and reinstated the original $24 million verdict in full, along with the sanctions.
Sources
This account is drawn from contemporaneous public reporting and the court record.
- 1.Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineers and Trainmen: Judge finds BNSF railroad guilty of misconduct·Archived copy
- 2.Minnesota Lawyer: Paul Godlewski, Schwebel Goetz and Sieben (March 2009)·Archived copy
- 3.Frazier v. BNSF Railway Co., Minn. Court of Appeals A09-2212 (Sept. 14, 2010)
- 4.Meshbesher and Spence: Minnesota Supreme Court upholds $24 million verdict (April 2012)·Archived copy
More proven verdicts from Schwebel, Goetz & Sieben, P.A.
All Schwebel, Goetz & Sieben, P.A. proven verdicts →James Schwebel represented 34 victims in a three-year lawsuit against engineering firm URS Corp, whose negligent inspection of the Minneapolis I-35W bridge preceded its August 2007 collapse, killing 13 people and injuring 145 others.
A six-week Anoka County trial ended with a $24 million jury verdict against BNSF Railway after four young people died at a malfunctioning Ferry Street grade crossing in September 2003.
A Hennepin County jury awarded $5.33 million after a Metro Transit bus driver closed the doors and pulled away while Christopher Swickard was approaching, causing the rear wheels to run over him and require amputation of his left leg below the knee.
After a Federal Signal flasher on a Minneapolis police van disabled the brake-shift interlock and the van surged into a Holidazzle Parade crowd, killing two and injuring nine, James R. Schwebel and James S. Ballentine of Schwebel, Goetz and Sieben won a precedent-setting appeal holding that a self-insured municipality must pay no-fault benefits independent of the municipal tort liability cap.
Related wrongful death verdicts
In December 2011, a Fayette County, Texas jury awarded the family of an 8-year-old Splendora boy $150.37 billion after he was doused with gasoline and set on fire by a 13-year-old neighbor in 1998, two weeks after the same neighbor sexually assaulted him. The boy survived third-degree burns over 99 percent of his body for nearly 13 years before dying in April 2011 of a skin cancer linked to his injuries. The defendant, Don Wilburn Collins, never appeared to answer the civil suit, and the jury awarded $370 million in actual damages plus roughly $150 billion in punitive damages, the largest civil verdict in U.S. history. Attorney Craig Sico, who represented the family, said from the outset that the judgment was not collectible and was intended to pressure prosecutors into reopening the long-dormant criminal case. Prosecutors did reopen the case, and Collins was later convicted of capital murder in a separate criminal proceeding.
A Pensacola jury awarded Cynthia Robinson $23.6 billion in punitive damages against R.J. Reynolds over the 1996 lung cancer death of her 36-year-old husband, the largest single-plaintiff award of Florida's Engle tobacco litigation, but the trial judge called the number constitutionally excessive, an appeals court ordered a full retrial over improper closing arguments, and a second jury returned a complete defense verdict in 2019, so the estate ultimately collected nothing.
Frantz Law Group, representing roughly 5,000 victims, helped negotiate a $13.5 billion PG&E bankruptcy settlement covering tens of thousands of survivors and families from the 2015 Butte, 2017 North Bay, and 2018 Camp wildfires.