Jury Verdict Over Snow Machine Death Near Barrow
After trial: The jury's $1,756,365 award was reduced under Alaska's noneconomic damages cap (AS 09.17.010) to $1,280,675, the figure stated in the Alaska Supreme Court's opinion. The court affirmed the denial of a new trial or remittitur in 2009.
An 18-year-old died in May 2005 when his snow machine went into a hole in the ice near Barrow that North Slope Borough Public Works had dug. His mother, Isabel Brower, sued the Borough, and an August 2007 jury found it negligent and a legal cause of his death. The jury awarded $1,756,365. Alaska's cap on noneconomic damages cut the award to $1,280,675, and the Alaska Supreme Court affirmed in 2009.
What happened
Alfred Brower was 18 when he died in late May 2005. His snow machine went into a hole in the ice near Barrow, a hole that had been dug by the North Slope Borough's Department of Public Works. He was unmarried and lived in Barrow with his widowed mother, Isabel Brower. He did not have a steady job, but he hunted and fished for the subsistence foods the household ate, and he cooked, cleaned and did maintenance work around the house.
Isabel Brower sued the Borough in the Alaska Superior Court at Barrow, on her own behalf as a dependent of her son and as personal representative of his estate. She claimed the Borough's negligence caused his death and the pain and suffering he experienced before it. The case went to a jury in August 2007.
On August 11, 2007, the jury found the Borough negligent and found that its negligence was a legal cause of Alfred's death. It also found that Isabel had been dependent on him at the time and that his contributions to her support would have continued had he lived. The jury found Alfred himself negligent, but not a legal cause of his death, so his share of fault did not reduce the award.
The jury's verdict totaled $1,756,365. It was itemized as $400,000 for Alfred's pain and suffering before death, $250,000 for Isabel's past loss of her son's companionship and her own suffering, $62,250 for past loss of support and assistance, $200,000 for her future noneconomic loss, and $844,115 for future economic loss, reduced to present value.
Alaska law caps noneconomic damages in cases like this one under AS 09.17.010, and the parties agreed on how the cap applied. The trial court reduced the noneconomic portion of the verdict accordingly. The Alaska Supreme Court, in its opinion, put the amount of damages after the cap at $1,280,675. The trial court then added prejudgment interest, costs and attorney's fees to reach its final judgment.
The Borough moved for a new trial or a remittitur, and the trial court denied both. On appeal the Borough argued that Isabel should not have been allowed to recover damages both as a statutory beneficiary and as the estate's representative, that she had not proved she depended on her son's future earnings, and that his lifetime earnings should have been measured by her life expectancy rather than his. In its 2009 opinion in North Slope Borough v. Brower, 215 P.3d 308, the Alaska Supreme Court rejected each argument, relying on its earlier decision in Kulawik v. ERA Jet Alaska, and affirmed the denial of a new trial or remittitur. David Henderson of the Law Offices of David Henderson in Bethel represented Isabel Brower on appeal, as the opinion's counsel listing shows.
Sources
This account is drawn from contemporaneous public reporting and the court record.
More proven verdicts from The Law Offices of David Henderson
All The Law Offices of David Henderson proven verdicts →Phyllis Rivers, pregnant, was treated at the Alaska Native Medical Center in Anchorage. Her doctors noted at least three indicators of infective endocarditis, rejected that diagnosis in favor of pregnancy-induced vasculitis, stopped her antibiotics after four days and sent her home. Untreated, the infection caused a stroke that left her paralyzed. After a bench trial under the Federal Tort Claims Act the court entered a $22,000,000 judgment against the United States and found the doctors reckless, which lifted Alaska's $400,000 malpractice cap. The Ninth Circuit affirmed in 2018.
Related wrongful death verdicts
A Franklin County jury in June 2003 found a Rush Transportation driver liable for the death of motorcyclist Robert L. Beavers Jr., who was run over on Groveport Road in Columbus in October 2001 while the driver fled. The jury awarded $767,600 in compensatory damages plus punitive damages against the driver and the company. The Tenth District later threw out the punitive award against Rush but left the compensatory award, the driver's punitive award and the attorney fees in place.
A Montgomery County jury returned a $1.3 million gross verdict, reduced to approximately $1.27 million after Maryland statutory caps, for the parents of Ruben Bastien, a 23-year-old Army Reservist who died after an ER physician at Holy Cross Hospital in Silver Spring failed to act on an abnormal EKG and sent him home without cardiology consultation.
Robert Labat, a derrick hand on a Mallard Bay Drilling rig, fell ill in December 1999 and was left without medical evaluation until he was found convulsing; he died of bacterial meningitis a week later. The district court ruled for the company. The Louisiana Fourth Circuit reversed in 2002 and itself rendered an award to his widow for his pre-death pain and suffering, lost future earnings and the loss of guidance and support.
A 16-year-old boy drowned in March 2006 after an electric current immobilized him and three friends in Spring Lake, just south of De Soto, Missouri. In March 2009 a Jefferson County jury found that AmerenUE's underground cable caused the current and awarded his parents $1.25 million. The same jury made separate awards to two 15-year-olds who were critically injured.