Chevron Pays $756,000 Judgment After Wyoming Jury Finds It Mostly at Fault in a Truck Driver's Fatal Fall
After trial: The $756,000 judgment is the jury's $1.2 million damages finding cut to Chevron's 63 percent share of fault under Wyo. Stat. 1-1-109, which makes each actor liable only for its own percentage rather than the whole verdict. The remaining 37 percent went to Coffey's employer, which was not a defendant here and paid nothing under this judgment; anything the family received from the employer would have run through Wyoming's workers compensation system and is not part of this case's record. The court entered judgment on March 2, 2017, and Sharon Coffey filed a satisfaction of judgment on March 24, 2017, confirming Chevron paid. The docket shows no appeal. The jury's verdict form and the fault percentages it recorded are not public on the docket; the 63 and 37 percent split is as the firm and the judgment amount, which is exactly 63 percent of $1.2 million, both report it.
Won by The Spence Law Firm.
A federal jury in Casper found Chevron U.S.A. Inc. negligent in the February 2014 death of truck driver Thomas Coffey, who fell while loading molten sulfur from a three rail safety cage at Chevron's Glencoe Terminal near Kemmerer, Wyoming. The bottom rail of the cage was missing. The jury awarded Coffey's widow, Sharon Coffey, $1.2 million in wrongful death damages and apportioned fault at 63 percent to Chevron, 37 percent to Coffey's employer, and none to Coffey. Because Wyoming makes each actor answerable only for its own share of fault, the court entered judgment against Chevron for $756,000, which Chevron paid within the month. Noah W. Drew and Tyson Logan of The Spence Law Firm represented the widow.
What happened
On February 26, 2014, Thomas Coffey was loading molten sulfur into the top of a tanker trailer at Chevron's Glencoe Terminal near Kemmerer, Wyoming, when he fell and was killed. He was driving for Bonneville Transloaders Inc., which had been hired to haul the sulfur to a plant in Rock Springs. It was his first time loading at the Chevron facility, and his employer had sent a coworker along to train him.
Chevron had installed two custom three rail Carbis safety cages at the terminal so that workers loading trailers at that height would be enclosed while they worked. The bottom rail on both cages was gone. Chevron's terminal operator had noticed the missing rails at some point before 2014, and who cut them off, and why, was disputed throughout the case. Sharon Coffey's case was that her husband lost his balance lifting Chevron's loading arm and fell through the gap the missing rail left. Chevron's case was that he tripped on the truck's spill trough.
Sharon Coffey sued Chevron U.S.A. Inc. in the U.S. District Court for the District of Wyoming under the state's Wrongful Death Act, arguing the company controlled and maintained the modified cage, required drivers to use it, and failed to provide a reasonably safe place to work. Chevron argued it had ceded control of the loading equipment to the trucking company. In January 2017 the court denied Chevron summary judgment on liability but granted it on the claim for punitive damages, holding there was no evidence Chevron's conduct reached the willful and wanton standard Wyoming requires, a state of mind approaching an intent to do harm. The negligence claim went to a jury.
The case was tried before the Honorable Scott W. Skavdahl in Casper, to a jury of eight, from February 21 through March 1, 2017. Noah W. Drew and Tyson Logan of The Spence Law Firm represented Sharon Coffey at trial.
On March 1, 2017, the jury found Chevron negligent and set wrongful death damages at $1.2 million. It apportioned fault at 63 percent to Chevron, 37 percent to Coffey's employer, and none to Coffey himself. Under Wyo. Stat. 1-1-109, a Wyoming defendant answers only for its own percentage of fault, so the court entered judgment against Chevron for $756,000.00 on March 2, 2017, with post judgment interest at 0.82 percent. Coffey's employer was not a defendant and paid nothing under this judgment. Chevron paid, and Sharon Coffey filed a satisfaction of judgment on March 24, 2017.
Sources
This account is drawn from contemporaneous public reporting and the court record.
- 1.CourtListener RECAP: D. Wyo. docket, Coffey v. Chevron USA Inc, No. 2:16-cv-00001, naming Noah W Drew and Tyson Logan as counsel appearing for plaintiff Sharon Coffey, and recording the jury trial of February 21 to March 1, 2017 before Judge Scott W. Skavdahl, the March 2, 2017 judgment for $756,000.00 with post judgment interest at 0.82 percent, and the March 24, 2017 satisfaction of judgment
- 2.Law360, March 2, 2017: Jury Awards Widow $1.2M In Chevron Fatal Fall Suit, reporting the $1.2 million federal jury verdict against Chevron USA Inc. in the wrongful death case and listing The Spence Law Firm LLC among counsel
- 3.Order on Chevron's motion for summary judgment, D. Wyo., January 19, 2017: the Glencoe Terminal three rail Carbis safety cages with the bottom rails missing, Coffey's February 26, 2014 fall while loading for Bonneville Transloaders Inc., the parties' competing accounts of the fall, and the ruling denying summary judgment on liability while granting it on punitive damages
- 4.The Spence Law Firm (firm)
More proven verdicts from The Spence Law Firm
All The Spence Law Firm proven verdicts →After a seven-day bench trial in Sublette County, a Wyoming district court awarded APMTG Helium $35,199,276.79 against Denbury Onshore for failing to deliver helium under a long-term supply contract, and the Wyoming Supreme Court upheld the award in December 2020.
A Black Hawk County jury returned a $13.6 million verdict for Jarvis Lee Boggs, paralyzed when a Waterloo police officer ran a red light at 61 mph without lights or siren and slammed into his car at 12:45 a.m. on New Year's Eve 2008.
A federal jury in Wyoming awarded Amber Lompe $28.2 million after carbon monoxide from a faulty furnace caused permanent brain injury at her Casper apartment, a verdict that stood as one of the largest personal-injury awards in Wyoming history before the Tenth Circuit reduced the punitive component on due-process grounds.
A Sweetwater County jury returned a $5.19 million verdict for oilfield worker Blake Horr after a rubber well component, ejected by trapped pressure that Merit Energy's supervisor failed to relieve, shattered bones and severed nerves in his left hand and arm during a 2011 work-over operation in Bairoil, Wyoming.
Related workplace injury verdicts
After nearly 30 years of litigation, Markovits Stock and DeMarco secured a $742 million-plus-interest settlement for approximately 23,000 Navistar retirees whose healthcare and life insurance benefits had been repeatedly reduced.
Paul Napoli served as court-appointed co-liaison counsel for nearly 10,000 firefighters, police officers, and construction workers who developed respiratory diseases after working at Ground Zero, securing a settlement worth up to $712.5 million against the city and its contractors.
Sullivan Papain served as court-appointed co-liaison counsel in the World Trade Center Disaster Site Litigation, helping secure a settlement of more than $712 million for roughly 10,000 police officers, firefighters, and construction workers who developed serious respiratory and other illnesses after working in the toxic ruins of the World Trade Center.
Jose Valdivia, 25, was building scaffolding at the Phillips 66 refinery in Lake Charles when a co-worker above him lost his grip on a steel scaffold bar. It struck him on the head and spine through a hard hat and full protective equipment. He is in a wheelchair with limited speech. Brock never reported the accident to OSHA.