$10.8 Million Settlement for Navy Veteran Who Lost Leg in I-5 Chain-Reaction Crash
Won by CaseyGerry.
A Navy veteran lost his right leg and the use of his arm after a Navy-operated van triggered a chain-reaction crash on Interstate 5; CaseyGerry secured a $10.8 million settlement, described as the largest federal vehicle-collision settlement in San Diego history.
What happened
On September 13, 2019, Peter Arthur was riding his motorcycle on Interstate 5 near National City when a Navy sailor operating a government-owned van swerved lanes without warning, striking a vehicle ahead of Arthur and setting off a chain-reaction collision. The impact threw Arthur from his bike at highway speed.
Arthur, a 49-year-old Navy veteran with 20 years of service, sustained catastrophic injuries: above-the-knee amputation of his right leg, fractures to his femur, avulsion of his right biceps, and a complete laceration of the right radial nerve at the elbow. The nerve damage left him with severe, ongoing dysfunction in his arm. Before the crash Arthur had worked repairing and maintaining medical equipment at local hospitals; his injuries ended that career entirely.
The case was brought against the federal government for the sailor's negligence, with CaseyGerry partner Robert Francavilla leading Arthur's representation. The government's defense rested on a witness who claimed a phantom vehicle had swerved in front of the Navy van, shifting blame away from the sailor. Francavilla's team took depositions from everyone involved, including a critical deposition of that witness. As Francavilla put it, the witness "initially claimed to have seen a 'phantom' vehicle swerve in front of the Navy vehicle," but the testimony "failed to demonstrate that this phantom vehicle caused the collision, or even existed."
The settlement of $10.8 million was finalized on October 3, 2022, in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of California. Attorneys described it at the time as the largest personal-injury settlement arising from a vehicle collision against the federal government in San Diego history.
Arthur, who relies on a prosthetic leg and has compromised use of his right arm, cannot return to his previous work.
Sources
This account is drawn from contemporaneous public reporting and the court record.
More proven verdicts from CaseyGerry
All CaseyGerry proven verdicts →In multidistrict litigation before Judge Andrew J. Guilford, CaseyGerry served as class counsel in a $393.5 million settlement resolving allegations that Wells Fargo secretly loaded unnecessary collateral protection insurance onto auto loan accounts, pushing hundreds of thousands of borrowers into delinquency and causing roughly 27,000 wrongful vehicle repossessions.
As court-appointed lead plaintiffs' counsel, Morgan & Morgan's John Yanchunis negotiated the $117.5 million settlement resolving claims from Yahoo's 2013-2016 data breaches, the largest theft of personal data in history, touching roughly 3 billion accounts worldwide. Judge Lucy Koh approved the fund in 2020 after rejecting an earlier version as inadequate.
Gayle Blatt of CaseyGerry served as court-appointed co-lead counsel in a multidistrict proceeding against 23andMe, securing a $46.75 million settlement for approximately 6.9 million customers whose genetic ancestry profiles and personal data were stolen in a 2023 credential-stuffing attack.
Gayle Blatt of Casey Gerry served on the plaintiffs' leadership committee in the consolidated MDL arising from the 2011 hack of Sony's PlayStation Network, which exposed the personal data of approximately 77 million accounts, resulting in a $15 million class settlement.
Related motorcycle accident verdicts
A Waterbury jury awarded Don Zemo IV $45 million after finding that a tow truck illegally parked outside MyHoopty.com's Oakville lot blocked the sightline for a car pulling out, causing a collision that left him permanently paralyzed.
A Pierce County jury awarded $44.7 million to an EMT and volunteer firefighter left with permanent injuries after an SUV driver turned left through an uncontrolled intersection and into his path, a verdict Washington courts later upheld in full.
Shannon Shaw was riding his motorcycle in St. George, South Carolina, in September 2021 when an Amazon delivery van turned left across his path. He suffered a traumatic brain injury and orthopedic injuries that led to a cervical fusion. In December 2023 a Dorchester County jury found Amazon vicariously liable and grossly negligent and returned $44.63 million, including $30 million in punitive damages against Amazon.
A Marion County jury in March 2024 awarded $60.7 million to motorcyclist Christopher Dugan after a Tesla service manager crossed double yellow lines and struck him, leaving him with a permanent traumatic brain injury and a partial foot amputation; comparative fault reduced the net award to $42.5 million.