Federal Court Holds Excess Insurer Must Cover $2 Million for Mother and Daughters Hurt in Head-On Truck Crash
After trial: Harford Mutual appealed, and the Fourth Circuit affirmed on both coverage and interest on August 8, 2025. North Carolina Lawyers Weekly reports a total recovery of $2,861,458 including interest and the underlying auto coverage.
A mother and her two teenage daughters were seriously hurt in an October 2018 head-on crash on North Carolina Highway 49 with a company truck driven by an unlicensed man. After the injury claims were resolved by agreement, a federal court held that the construction company's commercial excess policy covered the accident and that interest was owed on top. The Fourth Circuit affirmed in August 2025, and the family's total recovery reached $2,861,458.
What happened
On October 27, 2018, Erica Chambers was driving south on North Carolina Highway 49 with her two teenage daughters when a truck owned by Big Boss Construction, Inc. crossed the center line and hit her car head on. The driver had no valid driver's license. The parties agreed he was working for the company at the time, on his way to finish a job for another contractor that was using the truck with Big Boss's permission.
Chambers spent 34 days in the hospital with broken bones throughout her body, including her face, jaw, back, legs and ribs. She wore a cranial halo for three months and had several surgeries that left hardware in her body. Some of her injuries are permanent. One daughter suffered a head injury that left her with continuing memory problems, and the other broke a leg.
The family sued the driver, Big Boss and the other contractor in North Carolina state court, alleging among other things that Big Boss negligently entrusted its truck to an unlicensed driver. The truck's underlying auto policy paid only a fraction of what the injuries called for. Big Boss also carried a commercial excess policy from Harford Mutual Insurance Group, Inc. Harford denied the claim, pointing to an exclusion for liability arising out of the use of any automobile.
Chambers brought a declaratory judgment action over that denial, and Harford removed it to federal court in Greensboro. The parties settled the underlying injury claims on terms that left the coverage question to the court. The district court granted judgment on the pleadings for the family. It reasoned that the same policy's aircraft and watercraft exclusion expressly reached entrustment, while the automobile exclusion did not, so the excess policy covered a negligent entrustment claim. It also held that Harford owed pre- and post-judgment interest.
Harford appealed, and the Fourth Circuit heard argument on March 18, 2025. In an unpublished opinion on August 8, 2025, the panel affirmed on both points. It held that North Carolina law requires an insurance policy to be read as a whole and that any ambiguity in an exclusion is construed against the insurer. Coleman Cowan argued the appeal for the family, with Kaitlyn Fudge on the brief, both of the Law Offices of James Scott Farrin.
The $2 million excess coverage, with interest, brought the family's total recovery to $2,861,458 more than six years after the crash, according to North Carolina Lawyers Weekly.
Sources
This account is drawn from contemporaneous public reporting and the court record.
More proven verdicts from Law Offices of James Scott Farrin
All Law Offices of James Scott Farrin proven verdicts →Farrin co-lead counsel Gary Jackson won an $8 million class settlement for roughly 6,500 residents forced from their homes by the 2022 ammonium nitrate fire at the Winston Weaver fertilizer plant, with a separate $4.5 million for affected businesses.
A Johnston County jury awarded $5.1 million to the family of Joan Drake, killed when a driver going 98 mph struck her car as she turned into a Clayton Walmart, after Farrin attorneys Coleman Cowan and Donald Clack tried the case without putting on a single medical bill.
Related car accident verdicts
A 35-year-old bicyclist left with a traumatic brain injury after a driver ran a stop sign recovered $2.3 million, approved within months and routed through a special needs trust so his care could continue.
A 30-year-old passenger was left tetraplegic after a speeding driver hit his stalled car on a South Carolina road, and Michael A. DeMayo stacked two liability policies and an umbrella policy to reach a $1.6 million settlement.
A licensed practical nurse who suffered a mild traumatic brain injury and six separate fractures in a Moore County crash recovered $879,000 through Joseph Tunstall of O'Malley Tunstall PC after the defense challenged whether her near-full return to work diminished the case value.
A jury awarded $760,035 to a news reporter who suffered a fractured tibia after a municipal truck driver struck and then backed over his leg in a Huntersville parking lot, and the NC Court of Appeals unanimously affirmed the verdict over a contributory-negligence challenge.