Judge Allows 88-Year-Old's Hip Fracture Suit Against Lyft and Santa Monica to Proceed
Won by McGee Lerer Ogrin.
In November 2019, a Los Angeles Superior Court judge overruled demurrers filed by Lyft and the City of Santa Monica, finding that an 88-year-old woman who sustained five pelvic fractures after tripping over a Lyft scooter in a posted no-deployment zone had stated viable negligence and public-nuisance claims against both defendants.
What happened
On September 24, 2018, Dorothy 'Dolly' Green, then 87 years old, was dropped off in a passenger loading zone in front of the Santa Monica Community College Emeritus campus. As she stepped onto the curb, she caught her foot on a Lyft electric scooter parked directly on the sidewalk and fell backward into the street.
Green sustained five fractures to her pelvis along with injuries to her hip and elbow, all of which required surgery. The loading zone where she fell had been designated a no-deployment zone under Santa Monica's Shared Mobility Pilot Program, which had launched just five days before the incident. Despite that designation, Lyft scooters were present in the zone and no enforcement action had been taken to remove them.
Catherine Lerer of McGee Lerer filed suit against Lyft, the City of Santa Monica, and the Santa Monica Community College District on Green's behalf. The complaint sought at least $500,000 in damages and alleged negligence and public nuisance. Both Lyft and the City moved to dismiss the case through demurrers, arguing they could not be held liable.
Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Theresa Traber disagreed. In her November 2019 ruling, Traber found that Lyft's practice of deploying dock-less scooters and permitting riders to leave them wherever they chose created a foreseeable safety risk. On the City, Traber wrote that Santa Monica's failure to impound scooters left in a no-deployment zone routinely used by older adults was 'an operational decision' rather than a protected basic policy choice, a distinction that stripped the City of government-immunity protection at the pleading stage. Both demurrers were overruled and the case was allowed to proceed.
No public record of a final verdict or disclosed settlement in the Green matter has been identified. The 2019 ruling was nonetheless significant: it was among the earliest California superior court decisions holding that dock-less scooter operators and the municipalities that permit them can face civil liability when scooters are left in zones explicitly closed to them.
Sources
This account is drawn from contemporaneous public reporting and the court record.
More proven verdicts from McGee Lerer Ogrin
All McGee Lerer Ogrin proven verdicts →McGee Lerer Ogrin represented 14 of the 124 survivors whose claims were resolved in a $122.5 million settlement with the City of Santa Monica over decades of child sexual abuse by a PAL volunteer the city failed to stop.
In a landmark April 2023 ruling, California's Second District Court of Appeal reversed dismissal of a pedestrian trip-and-fall lawsuit, holding that Bird Rides owes a general duty of ordinary care over its dock-less scooters and can be sued when improperly parked scooters injure members of the public.
Catherine Lerer of McGee Lerer, co-counseling with Costell & Cornelius, filed a class action in October 2018 against Bird, Lime, Xiaomi, and Segway on behalf of riders and pedestrians seriously injured by dockless e-scooters deployed across Los Angeles.
Related slip & fall verdicts
A Cook County jury awarded $32 million to truck driver Stephanie Johnson, who developed Complex Regional Pain Syndrome after slipping on oil at an ExxonMobil facility, in what the Jury Verdict Reporter recorded as the largest CRPS verdict in Illinois history.
After a neurosurgeon slipped on a wet hospital pantry floor and developed reflex sympathetic dystrophy that ended his surgical career, an Evansville jury found St. Mary's Medical Center fully at fault and awarded $16.95 million, a verdict the Indiana Court of Appeals later affirmed.
A Kern County jury awarded William Kidd and his wife Elaine $16.2 million after he slipped at a Bakersfield El Pollo Loco and suffered a brain injury that later required surgery.
A Clark County jury held Lowe's responsible after Kelly Hendrickson slipped on liquid draining from store planters, fractured her skull, and permanently lost her senses of taste and smell.