$11.39 Million Verdict for Shopper With Fractured Leg and Ankle at a Target Parking Lot Curb Seam
After trial: No post-trial motion, remittitur or appeal has been reported, though the verdict is recent and one may be pending. It is not stated whether the $11,391,183.28 is before or after any reduction for the plaintiff's share of fault.
Won by Morgan & Morgan.
A 44-year-old Winter Garden woman fractured her right tibia, fibula and lateral malleolus and her left ankle after catching her foot on an abrupt asphalt-to-gutter seam in the Super Target parking lot at Winter Garden Village on Dec. 23, 2019. On Oct. 17, 2025, an Orange County jury awarded $11,391,183.28 and found Target and property owner Site Centers 90 percent at fault. She had declined a pre-trial offer and tried the case.
What happened
On December 23, 2019, a 44-year-old Winter Garden woman parked at the Super Target in the Winter Garden Village shopping center on Daniels Road. It was the holiday rush and there were puddles in the lot, so she picked her way between parked cars while carrying her young daughter. Near a landscaping island she stepped onto the seam where the asphalt met the concrete gutter of the curb.
The seam was an unmarked, abrupt change in elevation. Her left ankle twisted and fractured, and she fell to the right. Trying not to drop her child, she landed with her right leg bent awkwardly beneath her. The fall fractured her right tibia, fibula and lateral malleolus, in addition to the left ankle. She needed multiple surgeries, and she now has metal rods and screws permanently in her right leg.
She sued Target Corporation and Site Centers Corp, the owner of the Winter Garden Village property. Her claim was that the uneven surface and sudden drop in height violated several building codes and that neither company had fixed or marked it. The defendants disputed the case, and it did not settle. The woman declined the defense's highest pre-trial offer and took the case to a jury in Orange County Circuit Court.
On October 17, 2025, the jury returned a verdict of $11,391,183.28. It found Target and Site Centers 90 percent at fault. The published accounts do not say whether the verdict figure was reduced for the remaining share of fault, and they do not break the award into its parts.
Morgan & Morgan attorneys Matt Morgan, Fan Li and Perry Nava represented her. In comments quoted by CBS News, Matt Morgan and Fan Li said their client suffered a devastating and lifelong injury and lives with pain and limitations from the hardware in her leg, and that the verdict 'spoke the full truth as to the level of human harms and losses sustained.' Target declined to comment when contacted by reporters.
The case went from a fall in a parking lot to a trial verdict in just under six years. We found no report of a post-trial motion or appeal as of this writing, though the verdict is recent enough that one could still be pending.
Sources
This account is drawn from contemporaneous public reporting and the court record.
More proven verdicts from Morgan & Morgan
All Morgan & Morgan proven verdicts →A jury found the owners of the Park Social bar liable for a 2017 staircase fall that left a 57-year-old patron a partial quadriplegic, returning a $644,751,855 premises-liability verdict that the defendants have appealed to Florida's Sixth District Court of Appeal.
A federal jury in San Francisco found Google liable for invasion of privacy and intrusion upon seclusion after the company kept collecting data from third-party apps for users who had switched off the Web & App Activity setting. On September 3, 2025, the jury awarded $425,651,947 in compensatory damages and declined to award punitive damages. The award is a single class-wide figure shared by two nationwide classes of about 98 million users, not one person's recovery. The judge refused to set the verdict aside in August 2026, and Google has appealed to the Ninth Circuit.
Hours before opening arguments in the first federal opioid bellwether trial, Cuyahoga and Summit counties in Ohio secured a $260 million settlement from distributors AmerisourceBergen, Cardinal Health, and McKesson, plus manufacturer Teva.
Morgan & Morgan's John Yanchunis served as court-appointed co-lead counsel in the multidistrict litigation over Capital One's 2019 data breach, which exposed the personal information of roughly 98 million U.S. customers. The $190 million settlement won final approval in 2022 as one of the largest data breach recoveries in U.S. history.
Related premises liability verdicts
A Duval County jury returned an $18.74 million verdict after Joshua Mathews suffered a traumatic brain injury in a 2012 assault outside Pete's Bar in Neptune Beach.
Yaimi Guevara Machado was locked out of her room at the Chesapeake Motel in Hialeah in the early hours of April 10, 2016, and the front desk refused to let her back in. Motel security had already been warned about an intoxicated man who was not a registered guest, Ronald Lopez Andrade, after he harassed a housekeeper, and left him on the property anyway. Machado was killed soon afterward, and her body was found in a grassy area on the motel grounds. A Miami-Dade jury awarded her parents $12 million against the motel's owner, The Waves of Hialeah, Inc., on December 1, 2017, assigning her no share of the fault. Florida's Third District Court of Appeal affirmed the verdict in full on February 19, 2020, rejecting the motel's challenges to excluded evidence and to a directed verdict that cleared her companion of any share of blame.
Stuart Grossman secured a $10.75 million settlement for Bernard Barlow, a Massachusetts vacationer who broke his neck diving from the Galleon Resort's tiki bar deck in April 2015 after the tide receded and the resort posted no warnings.
Goldberg and Rosen secured a $13 million jury verdict on behalf of a man left near death after a nightclub bouncer's felony battery, but a Miami judge vacated the award in 2024 and ordered a new trial after finding the defendants were wrongly barred from presenting certain defenses.