Ada County Jury Awards $3.79 Million After Sepsis Death Following Boise-Area Liposuction
After trial: The Idaho Supreme Court affirmed the judgment on 4 August 2016, including the $1,250,000 noneconomic award, which the statutory cap did not reach because the jury found reckless conduct. It vacated only a separate attorney-fee award for the first trial's mistrial and remanded for findings.
Won by Nevin, Benjamin & McKay LLP.
Krystal Ballard, a 27-year-old Air Force staff sergeant, died of sepsis days after liposuction and a fat transfer at Silk Touch Laser, a medical spa in Eagle, Idaho. After a first trial ended in a mistrial, an Ada County jury in 2014 found the spa and its owner reckless and awarded her husband $3,790,436. The Idaho Supreme Court affirmed the judgment on 4 August 2016, apart from one fee award.
What happened
On 21 July 2010, Krystal Ballard, a 27-year-old Air Force staff sergeant stationed at Mountain Home, had liposuction and a fat transfer at Silk Touch Laser, a medical spa in Eagle, Idaho. The practice was owned by Dr. Brian Kerr, an anesthesiologist who had been trained in the procedure about three years earlier.
Two days later she called the spa in severe pain. Dr. Kerr examined her, judged the wounds to look normal, and started an antibiotic. On 24 July she asked her husband, Charles, to call 911. She was taken to Elmore Medical Center and then flown to St. Alphonsus in Boise in septic shock. She went into cardiac arrest four times and died on the evening of 25 July.
The Ada County coroner's pathologist found gram-negative bacteria deep in the fat of her right buttock, at the fat-transfer injection site, and no other source of infection in her body. The cause of death was recorded as sepsis with probable toxic shock. The claim against Silk Touch and Dr. Kerr was that the spa had no written policy for disinfecting and sterilizing the reusable handpiece, cannulas and canister used in her procedure, and relied on chemical autoclave indicators without biological ones.
Charles Ballard sued for wrongful death and medical malpractice. The first trial ended in a mistrial after the defense's own standard-of-care expert violated a pretrial order. The district court, Judge Deborah Bail, later found the defense conduct in that trial so outrageous that she had not seen such a pattern in more than three decades of complex litigation, and awarded Ballard fees for the mistrial.
The retrial ran from 16 September to 2 October 2014 in the Fourth Judicial District in Ada County. On a special verdict form, the jury found that the actions of the defendants that breached the standard of care and caused Krystal Ballard's death were reckless. It awarded $3,790,436: $2,540,436 in economic damages and $1,250,000 in noneconomic damages. Judgment was entered on 15 October 2014. The recklessness finding mattered because Idaho's statutory cap on noneconomic damages in injury and death cases does not apply to reckless conduct.
The defense appealed on several grounds. On 4 August 2016 the Idaho Supreme Court affirmed the judgment, finding substantial evidence supporting the verdict, and upheld the award of costs. It vacated only the attorney-fee award for the first trial's mistrial and sent that question back because the district court had not made the findings the rule requires. Bailey & Glasser, LLP, of Morgantown, West Virginia, and Nevin, Benjamin, McKay & Bartlett, LLP, of Boise, appeared for Ballard on appeal, and Scott McKay argued the case before the Supreme Court.
Sources
This account is drawn from contemporaneous public reporting and the court record.
- 1.Ballard v. Kerr, 160 Idaho 674, 378 P.3d 464 (Idaho Supreme Court, Aug. 4, 2016)·Archived copy
- 2.Ballard v. Kerr, M.D., Silk Touch Laser, Docket No. 42611, Idaho Supreme Court, Aug. 4, 2016
- 3.Claims Journal, 'Idaho Supreme Court Affirms $3.8M Verdict in Liposuction Death', Aug. 10, 2016·Archived copy
- 4.Respondent's Brief, Ballard v. Kerr, Docket No. 42611, Idaho Supreme Court, Oct. 5, 2015·Archived copy
Related wrongful death verdicts
A 15-year-old boy died when a Blaine County School District driver-education car was struck during a three-point turn on U.S. Highway 20 near Carey in snow and fog. In 2013 a Blaine County jury found the instructor entirely at fault and reckless, and awarded the boy's parents about $3.51 million. The Idaho Supreme Court affirmed the verdict on 30 March 2015.
BSR Ventures, doing business as Advanced Heating and Cooling, agreed to a $5 million judgment after its employee, who had seven prior DUI convictions including two felonies, crossed the center line on U.S. 93 and killed Cheryl Miller in a head-on crash.
Delbert Hayward, 86, a mechanic, died in February 1995 after nearly a year at Valley Vista Care Center in St. Maries, Idaho, where his family said he was repeatedly given the antipsychotic drug Haldol to control him. After a three-week trial in May 2006, a Benewah County jury returned an $18 million punitive verdict. By November 2006 the case had resolved in a $3.5 million settlement, most of it paid by the home's insurers.
A Denver jury awarded $31.8 million to the family of an 82-year-old woman killed and other residents injured when a punctured Xcel Energy gas line exploded at Heather Gardens retirement community in 2018, assigning Xcel 12% of the fault.