The Card Reader on the Hotel Door Was Broken, So Anyone Could Walk In. The Cameras Recorded the Night Clerk's Murder, and Nobody Was Watching Them. A DeSoto Parish Jury Put Half the Blame on the Motel.
After trial: Reduced by the jury's own fault allocation, not by a court. The $4,000,000 verdict of February 21, 2025 carried a 50 percent assessment to the motel and 50 percent to the murderer, so under Louisiana's comparative-fault regime (La. C.C. art. 2323 and 2324) the amount cast to the motel is $2,000,000. The Louisiana Jury Verdict Reporter is the only source for the verdict; it reports no entered judgment, JNOV or appeal, DeSoto Parish has no public docket search, and the caption and docket number are unconfirmed. The pre-trial settlement with the hotel operator is undisclosed and is not included. Collectability: no source reports payment, so the disclosure stays at not public. Attribution: the firm has since become Scott Chafin Law.
Won by Scott Chafin Law.
Lynda Palmer, 75, was working the night shift at the front desk of the Best Western Plus DeSoto Inn & Suites in Mansfield, Louisiana on April 12, 2021 when she was shot and killed in a robbery. The card reader that controlled entry to the hotel was broken, and although the surveillance cameras recorded the entire crime, nobody was monitoring them. On February 21, 2025 a DeSoto Parish jury awarded her two adult daughters $2,000,000 each and assessed 50 percent of the fault to the motel, leaving $2,000,000 cast to it.
What happened
Lynda Palmer was 75 and working the overnight shift as the desk clerk at the Best Western Plus DeSoto Inn & Suites in Mansfield, Louisiana. On April 12, 2021 a man came in to rob the hotel and shot her. She died. He was later convicted and sentenced to life.
The civil case her two adult daughters brought was about how he got in and why nobody saw him coming. The card reader that controlled entry to the hotel was broken, so the door did not lock and anyone could walk in. The property had surveillance cameras, and they captured the whole crime. Nobody was watching them.
The daughters settled with the company that operated the hotel on undisclosed terms and took the case against the Best Western parent to trial in the 42nd Judicial District Court in Mansfield, before Judge Amy Burford McCartney. On February 21, 2025 the jury awarded $2,000,000 to each daughter for her mother's wrongful death, $4,000,000 in all, and assessed 50 percent of the fault to the motel and the remainder to the murderer. Louisiana's comparative-fault rule makes each defendant liable only for its own share, so the amount cast to the motel is $2,000,000.
Scott J. Chafin Jr. and Marshall Johnston of what was then Gregorio Chafin & Johnston in Shreveport tried the case for the family. Richard G. Duplantier Jr. and Henry M. Weber of Galloway Johnson Tompkins Burr & Smith in New Orleans defended.
Sources
This account is drawn from contemporaneous public reporting and the court record.
- 1.Louisiana Jury Verdict Reporter blog: the February 21, 2025 DeSoto Parish verdict before Judge Amy Burford McCartney; the broken card reader and unmonitored cameras; the $4,000,000 award, $2,000,000 to each daughter, assessed 50 percent to the motel; the settlement with the operator before trial; and counsel Scott J. Chafin Jr. and Marshall Johnston of Gregorio Chafin and Johnston, Shreveport, for the plaintiff, with Richard G. Duplantier Jr. and Henry M. Weber of Galloway Johnson Tompkins Burr & Smith for the defense
- 2.KTAL: the criminal conviction and life sentence of the man who shot and killed the motel clerk during the April 2021 robbery in Mansfield
More proven verdicts from Scott Chafin Law
All Scott Chafin Law proven verdicts →AIX Energy ordered a workover cleanout on a Claiborne Parish well using completion fluid far too light to hold back the formation's gas pressure, and never wrote or circulated a completion plan to the crew. Gas broke out and ignited. Jeremy Shephard, the toolpusher, was burned over a third to half of his body.
Related premises liability verdicts
Appointed by the court as Plaintiffs Liaison Counsel and Co-Lead Class Counsel, Stephen Herman of Herman Herman and Katz helped negotiate a $7.8 billion economic and property-damage class settlement with BP covering more than 100,000 Gulf Coast businesses and individuals harmed by the 2010 Deepwater Horizon oil spill.
Anapol Weiss shareholder Kristen Gibbons Feden helped secure $1.6 billion in default verdicts for 104 women sexually abused as children by former Long Island pediatrician Stuart Copperman, one of the largest cumulative civil awards against a single individual in U.S. history.
Saltz Mongeluzzi and Bendesky joined the plaintiffs' leadership team that secured a $1.2 billion settlement for the families and survivors of 98 people killed when Champlain Towers South collapsed in Surfside, Florida on June 24, 2021 -- the largest construction-disaster settlement in U.S. history.