$1.94 Million Verdict Against ExxonMobil in Wrongful Death of Houston Father
After trial: The Texas Supreme Court reversed the judgment in 2017, ruling that the employer owed no supervisory duty under the circumstances.
Won by Sutliff & Stout.
Sutliff and Stout won a $1.94 million wrongful death verdict against ExxonMobil for the family of Alfredo Pagayon, a Harris County man who died after an ExxonMobil cashier attacked him at a Houston convenience store; the Texas Supreme Court reversed the judgment in 2017, ruling that the employer owed no supervisory duty under the circumstances.
What happened
Alfredo M. Pagayon, a Harris County toll booth attendant, arrived at an Exxon convenience store in Houston to pick up his son. His son, Alfredo G. Pagayon Jr., known as J.R., worked there as a cashier alongside a coworker named Carlos Cabulang, age 54. Weeks of friction between J.R. and Cabulang had escalated into verbal threats and harassment. J.R. reported the problem to the store manager and was told to ignore it. Shortly before the assault, Alfredo Sr. called Cabulang directly to demand the harassment stop; the conversation turned hostile.
When Alfredo entered the store the following Monday, Cabulang was already screaming and cursing at J.R. and Alfredo. Cabulang attacked Alfredo, punching him in the head and back. Bystanders separated them, and Alfredo left by ambulance. He died twenty-three days later from sepsis that developed into cardiac arrhythmia, respiratory failure, and renal failure.
Alfredo's widow, Delia Pagayon, and their family filed a wrongful death action in Harris County Probate Court No. 2. Attorneys Graham Sutliff and Hank Stout of Sutliff and Stout represented the plaintiffs, with Austin appellate lawyer Matthew Ploeger serving as co-counsel. The firm built its case around ExxonMobil's negligent supervision of Cabulang. Cabulang had no documented history of violence, but management had received J.R.'s complaints and taken no action. The firm argued that the warning signs of escalating hostility were present and that ExxonMobil's failure to intervene made the company responsible for what followed.
The jury agreed. It apportioned 75 percent of fault to ExxonMobil, 15 percent to J.R., and 10 percent to Alfredo, and returned a verdict of approximately $1.94 million for the family.
ExxonMobil challenged the verdict at the Fourteenth Court of Appeals in Houston. That court affirmed the negligent supervision liability theory but reversed on a separate procedural issue and remanded for a new trial. The Pagayon family petitioned the Texas Supreme Court to restore the original verdict.
In June 2017, the Texas Supreme Court reversed both courts and rendered judgment in ExxonMobil's favor, eliminating the family's recovery. Chief Justice Nathan Hecht, writing for a seven-justice majority, held that an employer in this situation owed no legal duty to supervise its employees against the type of spontaneous conflict that arose here. The court reasoned that the likelihood a personal grievance over a phone call would escalate into a fatal fight was too low to impose a supervisory obligation on the company. The opinion is reported at Pagayon v. Exxon Mobil Corp., 536 S.W.3d 499 (Tex. 2017).
Sources
This account is drawn from contemporaneous public reporting and the court record.
- 1.Justia: Pagayon v. Exxon Mobil Corp., 536 S.W.3d 499 (Tex. 2017) - Texas Supreme Court opinion·Archived copy
- 2.SCOTX Blog: Case No. 15-0642 docket·Archived copy
- 3.Justia: ExxonMobil Corp. v. Pagayon, 467 S.W.3d 36 (Tex. App. 14th Dist. 2015)·Archived copy
- 4.FindLaw: Pagayon v. Exxon Mobil Corp., 536 S.W.3d 499 (Tex. 2017) - Texas Supreme Court opinion·Archived copy
More proven verdicts from Sutliff & Stout
All Sutliff & Stout proven verdicts →After a Detmar Logistics frac sand truck fatally injured Nanasha Ra-Nee Mild in 2018, Sutliff & Stout identified six liable parties and secured a $6.09 million settlement that ranked ninth among all Texas civil settlements in 2019.
A Montgomery County jury found a driver 70 percent liable for striking a 16-year-old pedestrian who had crossed outside a marked crosswalk, awarding $38,124.88 that was reduced to $26,687.42 after comparative-fault apportionment.
Related wrongful death verdicts
In December 2011, a Fayette County, Texas jury awarded the family of an 8-year-old Splendora boy $150.37 billion after he was doused with gasoline and set on fire by a 13-year-old neighbor in 1998, two weeks after the same neighbor sexually assaulted him. The boy survived third-degree burns over 99 percent of his body for nearly 13 years before dying in April 2011 of a skin cancer linked to his injuries. The defendant, Don Wilburn Collins, never appeared to answer the civil suit, and the jury awarded $370 million in actual damages plus roughly $150 billion in punitive damages, the largest civil verdict in U.S. history. Attorney Craig Sico, who represented the family, said from the outset that the judgment was not collectible and was intended to pressure prosecutors into reopening the long-dormant criminal case. Prosecutors did reopen the case, and Collins was later convicted of capital murder in a separate criminal proceeding.
A Pensacola jury awarded Cynthia Robinson $23.6 billion in punitive damages against R.J. Reynolds over the 1996 lung cancer death of her 36-year-old husband, the largest single-plaintiff award of Florida's Engle tobacco litigation, but the trial judge called the number constitutionally excessive, an appeals court ordered a full retrial over improper closing arguments, and a second jury returned a complete defense verdict in 2019, so the estate ultimately collected nothing.
Frantz Law Group, representing roughly 5,000 victims, helped negotiate a $13.5 billion PG&E bankruptcy settlement covering tens of thousands of survivors and families from the 2015 Butte, 2017 North Bay, and 2018 Camp wildfires.