Washington Township Schools Pay $245,000 to Four North Central Students Over Drama Teacher's Abuse
Won by Wagner Reese, LLP.
Four former North Central High School students settled their federal suit against the Metropolitan School District of Washington Township for $245,000 after alleging the district ignored years of warnings about a drama teacher's grooming, with Wagner Reese's Jeff Gibson representing the plaintiffs.
What happened
Nathan Shewell taught drama and directed the theater program at North Central High School in Indianapolis, part of the Metropolitan School District of Washington Township. He held the job from 2013 until the district fired him in 2020. In May 2022, four of his former students filed a federal lawsuit in the Southern District of Indiana, claiming that administrators had been warned about his behavior for years and let it continue.
The complaint laid out a pattern of grooming that, the plaintiffs said, began when some of them were as young as fourteen. It alleged that Shewell used acting exercises to make female students reenact past trauma, led students into a closet to act out sexual assaults, commented on their bodies, and subjected them to unwanted physical contact. The filing put it plainly: "Shewell preyed on these young women, grooming them from age fourteen to become sexual partners."
All four plaintiffs were former female students who said the conduct caused lasting harm. One sued under her own name; the other three proceeded as Jane Does. Jeff Gibson, an attorney with Wagner Reese in Carmel, represented them together with Texas lawyer Michelle Simpson Tuegel, who has handled sexual abuse cases nationally.
Much of the case centered on what school officials knew. The plaintiffs alleged that staff, including then-principal Evans Branigan III, were aware of complaints about Shewell as early as 2014 and did, in the words of the complaint, "absolutely nothing." When parents raised concerns about his relationships with students, the lawsuit said, Branigan told them to "leave the theater program alone."
On March 22, 2023, the Washington Township school board approved a settlement at a public meeting, paying the four plaintiffs a combined $245,000. The individual shares ranged from $20,250 to $87,000. The agreement ended every claim against the district before the case reached a jury. Gibson declined to comment on the resolution.
The district did not concede fault. The settlement states that it "continues to deny any liability toward the plaintiffs," and the plaintiffs agreed not to disclose the financial terms or publicly disparage the district. Because the matter resolved by agreement rather than trial, no verdict existed to appeal or reduce.
Sources
This account is drawn from contemporaneous public reporting and the court record.
- 1.Chalkbeat Indiana: Washington Township board settles abuse lawsuit involving North Central High School·Archived copy
- 2.WRTV: Washington Twp. reaches settlement in federal lawsuit claiming teacher misconduct·Archived copy
- 3.WFYI: Washington Township schools settle sexual harassment, abuse lawsuit·Archived copy
More proven verdicts from Wagner Reese, LLP
All Wagner Reese, LLP proven verdicts →A Richmond obstetrician ordered a contraction stress test instead of the recommended non-stress evaluation as a 34-week fetus showed distress, and a Wayne County jury held him responsible for the baby's death.
The mother of M. Shane Satterfield, 38, recovered $640,000 from Decatur County's liability insurer after he died of untreated alcohol withdrawal while serving a drunk-driving sentence at the county jail.
Roughly two dozen women sued after a Clark County jail officer sold cell keys to male detainees, and the county's insurer paid $328,000 to settle the federal suits that Wagner Reese helped bring.
Indianapolis paid $150,000 in 2013 to settle the federal civil rights suit of Brandon Johnson, a 15-year-old beaten by IMPD officers during his younger brother's 2010 arrest, with Stephen Wagner of Wagner Reese representing him.
Related sexual abuse verdicts
A Riverside County jury awarded $2.28 billion on April 25, 2023, to a woman identified as Jane Doe who was sexually abused by her stepfather from age 5 until she was 14, at the family's Lake Elsinore home and at events and property of the local Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. The stepfather, who had pleaded guilty in 1997 to lewd acts with a child under 14 and served three years in state prison, admitted the abuse at deposition, then skipped the first day of jury selection and withdrew his answer rather than face a bench warrant. The church settled for $1 million and the mother for $200,000 before trial. The verdict, $836 million in compensatory damages and $1.44 billion in punitive damages after three days of deliberation, is one of the largest ever returned for a single survivor of childhood sexual abuse.
A Rio Arriba County jury held Acadia Healthcare and its New Mexico foster care subsidiaries responsible for placing an 8-year-old girl with a foster father who raped her repeatedly, returning one of the largest single-plaintiff sexual abuse verdicts in the country.
A St. Charles County judge entered a $300 million bench-trial judgment for a child, identified only as G.T., who was physically and sexually abused between the ages of three and five while in the care of Susan and James McLaurie, though one defendant died before the suit was filed and the only known insurance was a $303,000 policy.
A St. Charles County jury awarded $247.3 million to six women sexually assaulted by an unlicensed massage therapist at Oasis Foot Spa & Massage in St. Peters, finding the spa and its owner liable for hiring him without any background check and ignoring an early complaint. The Missouri Court of Appeals affirmed the judgment in full in 2024.