$750,000 Stood After Virginia Cap Cut $2.75 Million Verdict to Brain-Injured Mother After Jaw Surgery
After trial: The trial court reduced the $2.75 million jury verdict to the $750,000 statutory cap for medical malpractice, and the Supreme Court of Virginia affirmed on January 13, 1989, upholding the cap. The opinion does not state trial counsel or the trial year.
Won by Levy Konigsberg LLP.
Richie Lee Wilson, a 35-year-old licensed practical nurse and mother of three, was left with brain damage and left-sided paralysis after jaw reconstruction surgery at Medical Center Hospitals in May 1980. A Virginia jury found the hospital and the general surgeon negligent and awarded $2.75 million. The trial court cut the judgment to the $750,000 statutory cap for medical malpractice, and in January 1989 the Supreme Court of Virginia upheld the cap against constitutional challenge, so $750,000 stood.
What happened
On May 6, 1980, Richie Lee Wilson, a 35-year-old licensed practical nurse and mother of three, went to Medical Center Hospitals in Virginia for surgery to restore a deteriorating jaw bone. Dr. Clarence B. Trower Jr., a general surgeon, removed five-inch-long portions of two of her ribs, and an oral surgeon grafted the reshaped rib bone onto her jaw.
Ms. Wilson had been healthy before the operation. She did not come out of it that way. She was left with permanent brain damage that limited her memory and intelligence, and with paralysis on her left side. She used a wheelchair afterward and could no longer care for herself or for her children. Because of her condition, her affairs were handled by co-committees of her estate, Louise Etheridge and Larry Dodd, who brought the case on her behalf.
The suit named the hospital and Dr. Trower, whose estate was later substituted as a defendant. At trial, the jury found both defendants negligent and found that their negligence was a proximate cause of Ms. Wilson's injuries. It returned a verdict of $2.75 million against them.
The verdict did not become the judgment. Virginia's medical malpractice statute, Code 8.01-581.15, capped total recoverable damages in a malpractice action, and the trial court reduced the award to the $750,000 limit. The case then turned on whether that cap could lawfully be applied to a jury's finding.
The plaintiffs appealed, with Donald I. Marlin as lead counsel and Alan J. Konigsberg of the New York firm Levy, Phillips & Konigsberg on the brief, together with Stephen C. Swain and Frederick T. Stant Jr. of Clark & Stant. They argued that the cap violated the federal and Virginia constitutions. The Attorney General of Virginia and the Medical Society of Virginia filed briefs supporting the statute.
On January 13, 1989, the Supreme Court of Virginia affirmed. Justice Stephenson wrote for the court and rejected the challenges based on the right to a jury trial, due process and equal protection, among others. The court also decided a question of statutory interpretation, holding that the malpractice cap controls over the general damages provision in Code 8.01-38. Justice Russell dissented, reasoning that the cap violated the Virginia Constitution's ban on special laws. The court's ruling left the $750,000 judgment in place, and the opinion became a frequently cited authority on the constitutionality of malpractice damage caps.
Sources
This account is drawn from contemporaneous public reporting and the court record.
More proven verdicts from Levy Konigsberg LLP
All Levy Konigsberg LLP proven verdicts →A Manhattan jury found in May 2019 that asbestos in Johnson's Baby Powder and Shower to Shower caused Donna Olson's pleural mesothelioma, awarding $25 million in compensatory damages and $300 million in punitive damages, the largest talc verdict in New York history. Jerome H. Block of Levy Konigsberg tried the case. The trial court cut the award to $120 million in November 2020, and on July 19, 2022 the Appellate Division, First Department reversed outright and directed judgment for Johnson & Johnson, holding that the plaintiffs' medical expert never gave a scientific expression of the minimum lifetime exposure needed to cause the disease.
Moshe Maimon of Levy Konigsberg led the trial team that won a $117 million verdict for Stephen Lanzo III, the first jury finding that Johnson & Johnson talc caused a plaintiff's mesothelioma. The New Jersey Appellate Division reversed the judgment in April 2021 over inadmissible expert testimony, and no retrial or final resolution has been publicly reported since, with J&J's talc bankruptcy filings stalling the litigation for years.
In the first consolidated multi-plaintiff talc trial, a Middlesex County jury awarded $37.3 million on September 11, 2019 to four people who developed mesothelioma after their parents powdered them with Johnson's Baby Powder as children, and a second jury added $750 million in punitive damages in February 2020, which Judge Ana Viscomi cut to $186.5 million under New Jersey's five-times cap. Moshe Maimon of Levy Konigsberg tried the case with Chris Placitella and Chris Panatier. On October 3, 2023 the Appellate Division reversed every judgment and ordered new trials, holding that the trial court had admitted three plaintiffs' experts without the gatekeeping New Jersey law requires.
A Bergen County jury awarded $30,312,204 in February 2008 to the family of Mark Buttitta, who died of mesothelioma at 50 after breathing asbestos fibers his father carried home from GM parts warehouses and after his own college summers working there. Moshe Maimon of Levy Konigsberg tried the case, and the New Jersey Appellate Division affirmed the full award on April 5, 2010.
Related medical malpractice verdicts
A Clark County jury ordered Health Plan of Nevada and Sierra Health Services to pay $524 million after finding the UnitedHealth Group subsidiaries negligently credentialed a gastroenterologist whose unsafe injection practices at his Las Vegas endoscopy clinics caused the largest medically caused hepatitis C outbreak in American history.
Georgia Hayes, a Kansas City area ovarian cancer patient, sued pharmacist Robert Courtney after learning he had diluted the chemotherapy drugs used in her treatment. A Jackson County jury found Courtney liable and awarded Hayes $225,571,439 in compensatory damages and $2 billion in punitive damages, the first of hundreds of similar suits against Courtney to reach trial. The trial judge later found the award excessive and cut it by remittitur to $330,071,439, and that reduced judgment stood. Hayes herself and the case reporter covering the verdict both said she was unlikely to ever collect a significant portion of it.
A Kansas City jury awarded ovarian cancer patient Georgia Hayes $225 million in compensatory damages and $2 billion in punitive damages against pharmacist Robert Courtney, who had diluted chemotherapy drugs for profit. The trial judge later reduced the award to roughly $330 million, and Hayes collected almost nothing from Courtney himself, whose assets had been seized by the federal government. Courtney was sentenced to 30 years in federal prison, and drug makers Eli Lilly and Bristol-Myers Squibb later paid $71 million to settle victims' claims.
A Detroit federal jury awarded former Michigan inmate Kohchise Jackson $307.6 million after the state's for-profit prison health contractor refused to pay for the $919 surgery that would have reversed his colostomy.