Proven verdicts

Top Mississippi Personal Injury Verdicts and Settlements

The 10 largest personal injury recoveries in Mississippi, ranked by amount, with 12 independently-sourced results to browse. Individual client results and group recoveries are both listed and labeled. Each links to the full story, the firm, and the record behind the number.

Browse personal injury lawyers in Mississippi
  1. $4,078,223VerdictCar Accidents

    The Guardrail Went Through the Engine and Speared Into the Passenger Cab. He Was Conscious for an Hour While They Cut Him Out.

    Matthew Feldman, 32, was a passenger being driven back to a work cabin by a co-worker who had been drinking. In heavy rain the driver hydroplaned at about 50 mph and hit a guardrail head-on. The rail went through the engine and into the passenger cab, pinning Feldman against the rear window. His right leg was amputated.

    After trial: Final at the full amount, and the reason is worth understanding. Mississippi caps noneconomic damages at $1,000,000 in non-medical civil actions under Miss. Code Ann. 11-1-60, but only $400,000 of this award was noneconomic, well under the ceiling, so there was nothing for the cap to reduce. A docket check of the Mississippi appellate courts found no appellate case for either Feldman or Parker, so no appeal was taken from the judgment. Note that this was a suit against a co-worker rather than an employer or a manufacturer; the defense was funded by insurance, and there is no public record of what was collected.

    Carroll Bufkin, PLLC2024 · Circuit Court of Newton County, MS (Decatur)Read the full story →
  2. $3,500,000 settlement (Harrison County's share; the jail's medical contractor and the City of Gulfport settled separately for undisclosed sums)SettlementCivil Rights

    Booked on Misdemeanors, He Was Beaten, Tasered, Pepper-Sprayed Through a Spit Mask and Strapped Into the Restraint Chair Prisoners Called the Torture Chair. He Was Brain Dead in Two Days. The Sergeant Got Life; the County Paid $3.5 Million.

    Jessie Lee Williams Jr., 40, a father of seven, was booked into the Harrison County Adult Detention Center in Gulfport on misdemeanor charges on February 4, 2006. In the booking room Sgt. Ryan Teel and other guards punched and kicked him while he was restrained, Tasered him, pepper-sprayed him through a spit mask, wrapped a soaked sheet over his face and beat him in a restraint chair. He was brain dead by February 6. Teel was sentenced to life. Harrison County settled the family's civil rights suit in July 2007 for $3,500,000.

    After trial: A settlement approved and funded in July 2007, so the figure is final by construction and no cap applied. The $3,500,000 is Harrison County's share alone: $1,000,000 from its insurer and $2,500,000 raised by county bonds. Health Assurance LLC, the jail's medical contractor, and the City of Gulfport settled separately for undisclosed amounts, so the family's total recovery is larger than the figure shown and not public. The original demand of $150,000,000 was a pleading figure and is not a result. Collectability: the payer is a county that issued bonds to fund the settlement; Prison Legal News reports the funding plan rather than the payment, so the disclosure stays at not public. Attribution: Michael W. Crosby's website carries no biography, so his practice is a record-only entry here with no profile page. Crosby received a public reprimand from the Mississippi Supreme Court in 2018 (Crosby v. Mississippi Bar, No. 2017-BA-00250-SCT) for failing to file a client's criminal appeal brief; under this site's discipline policy a reprimand is recorded and does not disqualify. The lawyer who appeared as co-counsel for the family was later permanently disbarred following federal felony convictions and is not credited here.

    Michael W. Crosby, Attorney at Law2007 · U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Mississippi, GulfportRead the full story →
  3. $3,400,000 judgment ($2,800,000 economic plus $600,000 noneconomic, Manitowoc's 40 percent share of an $8,500,000 verdict, affirmed)VerdictReduced from $8.5 millionProduct Liability

    When the Crawler Crane Tipped, the 18,000-Pound Counterweights Stacked on Its Back Slid Forward Into the Cab. The Manual Never Said They Could. A Gulfport Jury Returned $8.5 Million; the Judgment Was $3.4 Million.

    On June 25, 2014 John Williams Jr., a certified crane operator at the VT Halter Marine shipyard in Pascagoula, was in the cab of a Manitowoc Model 16000 crawler crane during a three-crane lift of a ship's bow when the cranes began pulling apart and his tipped. The 18,000-pound steel counterweights stacked on its rear slid forward and struck the cab, throwing him eight feet head-first onto concrete. He survived, permanently incapacitated. A Gulfport jury found Manitowoc never warned operators that could happen and awarded $8,500,000; after fault was split 50/40/10 the judgment against Manitowoc was $3,400,000, and the Fifth Circuit affirmed in 2018.

    After trial: Reduced by apportionment, not by a cap, and then affirmed. The October 2016 jury verdict was $8,500,000 ($7,000,000 economic, $1,000,000 noneconomic, $500,000 loss of consortium), but the jury put 50 percent of the fault on the employer VT Halter, 40 percent on Manitowoc and 10 percent on Williams, and under Mississippi's several-liability rule the court entered judgment against Manitowoc for its 40 percent share: $2,800,000 economic plus $600,000 noneconomic, $3,400,000 plus post-judgment interest. The $1,000,000 noneconomic award sat exactly at the Miss. Code Ann. 11-1-60 cap, so the cap made no further cut. Manitowoc's renewed motion for judgment as a matter of law and motion for a new trial were denied, and the Fifth Circuit affirmed on August 3, 2018 (No. 17-60458). Collectability: the payer is a crane manufacturer; no source reports the payment itself, so the disclosure stays at not public. Attribution: the trial firms were Owen, Galloway & Myers (now Owen, Owen & Smith) and Tobias, McCormick & Comer (now Tobias & Comer Law); the verdict is credited to the successor firms.

    Owen, Owen & Smith, PLLC2018 · U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Mississippi, GulfportRead the full story →
  4. $3,000,000 settlementSettlementCivil Rights

    The Cell Door Locks at the Hinds County Jail Had Been Broken Since It Opened in 1994. A Prisoner Jimmied One, Got In, and Body-Slammed a 23-Year-Old Until He Was Paralyzed From the Chest Down.

    On March 12, 2007 Michael Burnley, 23, was in his cell at the Hinds County jail in Raymond when another prisoner, John Earl Kennedy, jimmied the faulty lock on the door, got in, and repeatedly body-slammed him. Burnley was left paralyzed from mid-chest down. Sheriff Malcolm McMillin acknowledged the cell locks had been faulty since the jail opened in 1994, a fourteen-year-old defect that cost about $20,000 to fix. The county settled his Section 1983 suit on April 21, 2008 for $3,000,000.

    After trial: A settlement approved by the Hinds County Board of Supervisors on April 21, 2008, so the figure is final by construction and no cap applied; the county's insurer covered a third of it and the county funded the rest in installments beginning in May 2008. Collectability: the payer is a county under a board-approved installment schedule; Prison Legal News reports the schedule, not its completion, so the disclosure stays at not public. Attribution: Ellis Turnage is the only plaintiff's lawyer named in the reporting; he practises without a website, so his firm is a record-only entry here with no profile page.

    Turnage Law Office2008 · U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Mississippi, JacksonRead the full story →
  5. Approximately $2.8 million settlement (gross verdict $4,691,000)SettlementReduced from $4.7 millionMedical Malpractice

    The Hospital's Own File Already Said She Was Allergic to Latex. Nobody Read It, and the Court of Appeals Affirmed a Verdict the Parties Had Already Quietly Settled.

    Ellen Kelly died after latex exposure during surgery at Baptist Hospital in Jackson. A form from an earlier procedure at the same hospital already recorded her latex allergy. The jury found against the hospital and cleared the physicians, on the reasoning that the nurses and the doctors owed separate duties.

    After trial: Read the figure with care. The jury returned $4,691,000 in June 2009 in Hinds County Circuit Court before Judge Winston Kidd, and the Mississippi Court of Appeals affirmed it on December 13, 2011 in No. 2009-CA-01796-COA. But the parties had already settled in late November 2011, and two days after the opinion issued they jointly moved to dismiss the appeal and vacate it. The settlement figure of approximately $2.8 million comes from a single well-sourced legal blog which reported it as an understanding rather than a confirmed number, so it is approximate and is not confirmed to the dollar. We publish the approximate settlement because it is what was recovered, and we publish the $4,691,000 gross verdict alongside it because that is the figure the reported decision affirms. The $4,691,000 was never paid. On the cap: Miss. Code § 11-1-60 caps non-economic damages in medical-malpractice actions at $500,000, but the act complained of occurred in 2000 and suit was filed in 2001, before the statute, so no cap applied to the $2,253,065.48 the jury awarded for pain and suffering.

    Sweet & Associates, PLLC2011 · Hinds County Circuit Court, First Judicial District, MS (verdict affirmed, Miss. Ct. App.)Read the full story →
  6. $2,781,094.40 (affirmed; $4 million gross verdict before the cap)VerdictReduced from $4 millionCar Accidents

    The Jury Wrote One Number and Did Not Break It Down. That Is How a $4 Million Verdict Became $2.78 Million, and How Mississippi's Cap Survived a Constitutional Challenge.

    Lisa Learmonth was severely injured in August 2005 when a Sears van driven by a Sears employee collided with her vehicle. A federal jury returned a unanimous general verdict of $4 million without itemizing it, and that single choice set up a fight over Mississippi's damages cap that ran to the Fifth Circuit and the Mississippi Supreme Court.

    After trial: Affirmed and final at $2,781,094.40. The jury's general verdict was $4,000,000. The district court denied a new trial and remittitur but construed $2,218,905.60 of the award as noneconomic and reduced that component to the $1,000,000 statutory ceiling under Miss. Code Ann. 11-1-60. The Fifth Circuit had already affirmed the denial of a new trial in an earlier opinion at 631 F.3d 724 (2011) before certifying the constitutional question to the Mississippi Supreme Court, which declined to answer it (No. 2011-FC-00143-SCT, 95 So. 3d 633 (Miss. 2012)). The Fifth Circuit then upheld the cap against the jury-trial and separation-of-powers challenges and affirmed on February 27, 2013, revised March 20, 2013 (No. 09-60651, 710 F.3d 249).

    Hamilton Law Firm, PLLC2013 · U.S. District Court, Southern District of Mississippi, Eastern Division (Meridian)Read the full story →
  7. $2,759,094.32VerdictTruck Accidents

    The Car-Hauler Drifted Into Her Lane With No Signal and No Warning. A Deputy Noted the Compound Fracture at the Scene, and She Was Airlifted to Jackson.

    Ashley Newton was driving behind an automobile-hauler trailer on U.S. Highway 49 when its driver drifted across into her lane without signalling. She fractured a cervical vertebra in two places, her hip, her knee, and her tibia and fibula in compound fractures, and needed numerous surgeries.

    After trial: Final through certiorari denial, and the gross and final figures are the same number. The jury awarded $1,759,094.30 economic and $1,000,000 noneconomic on September 16, 2020. The noneconomic component sat exactly at the ceiling set by Miss. Code Ann. 11-1-60 for non-medical civil actions, so no cap reduction was available. The Mississippi Court of Appeals affirmed en banc on April 4, 2023 (No. 2021-CA-00684-COA) and the Mississippi Supreme Court denied certiorari on November 17, 2023 (No. 2021-CT-00684-SCT). Note that the accident happened in Yazoo County while the case was venued in Hinds County.

    Blackmon & Blackmon, PLLC2023 · Hinds County Circuit Court, First Judicial District, MS (affirmed; certiorari denied)Read the full story →
  8. $2,750,000 settlement ($2,500,000 from George County plus $250,000 from its insurer, certified as a judgment)SettlementCivil Rights

    An Insulin-Dependent Diabetic Went Seven Days in the George County Jail Without Insulin While the Nurse Called It Meth Withdrawal. He Died. She Got 15 Years for Manslaughter; the County Paid $2.75 Million.

    William Joel Dixon, 28, an insulin-dependent diabetic, was held in the George County Regional Correctional Facility in Lucedale in September 2014. For seven days he got no insulin. The jail nurse, Carmon Sue Brannan, dismissed his worsening condition as methamphetamine withdrawal. He died on September 24, 2014 of diabetic ketoacidosis. Brannan was convicted of manslaughter and sentenced to 15 years. In June 2022 George County agreed to pay his estate, his mother and his children $2,750,000.

    After trial: A settlement accepted by the estate on May 27, 2022 and certified as a judgment by the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Mississippi on May 31, 2022, so the figure is final by construction and no cap applied. Of the $2,750,000, the county pays $2,500,000 from its general fund and its insurer $250,000, with payment due in full by August 1, 2022; the county admits no fault and must write the family a letter of apology. The City of Lucedale was dismissed earlier. Collectability: the payer is a county under a court-certified schedule; WKRG reports the schedule rather than its completion, so the disclosure stays at not public. Attribution: WKRG identifies Garner Wetzel as co-counsel for the estate; the other co-counsel is not named in any source found.

    Wetzel Law Firm2022 · U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Mississippi, GulfportRead the full story →
  9. $2,000,000 to Michael Keith Howard (a separate $2,000,000 was awarded to Shannon Poole; both affirmed)VerdictPremises Liability

    Three Men Burst Through the Door of Their Extended-Stay Motel Room, Pistol-Whipped Him and Held the Gun to His Partner's Head. The Motel Knew Its Locks Did Not Work. The Cap Never Reached the Verdict, Because the Motel Never Asked for It.

    On June 27, 2008 Michael Keith Howard stepped out of his room at the InTown Suites extended-stay motel on the edge of Jackson to walk his dog. As he came back, three men burst through the door, hit him in the face with a handgun, held the gun to his partner Shannon Poole's head, and ransacked the room. Howard needed facial reconstructive surgery. The motel knew loiterers roamed the property, that its fence was in disrepair and that its room locks did not work. A Hinds County jury awarded Howard $2,000,000 and Poole a separate $2,000,000, and the Mississippi Supreme Court affirmed both in 2011.

    After trial: Affirmed in full. Judgment on the September 2009 verdict was entered September 25, 2009 and the Mississippi Supreme Court affirmed on June 30, 2011 (InTown Lessee Associates, LLC v. Howard, No. 2009-CA-01987-SCT, en banc). The Miss. Code Ann. 11-1-60 cap on noneconomic damages was never applied because InTown was held procedurally barred from raising it: it did not object to the verdict-form instruction or request an instruction separating economic from noneconomic damages. Scope: the verdict form required, and the jury returned, separately itemised awards of $2,000,000 to Michael Keith Howard and $2,000,000 to Shannon Poole; under this site's counting rule each is an individual result and neither is a grouped award, so the $4,000,000 total is never presented as one person's recovery. Collectability: the defendant is a motel operator; no source reports the payment, so the disclosure stays at not public. Attribution: Ogden & Associates has no website and is a record-only entry here with no profile page.

    Ogden & Associates, PLLC2011 · Hinds County Circuit Court, First Judicial District, Jackson MSRead the full story →
  10. $1,095,000 (including $500,000 punitive), affirmedProduct Liability

    He Worked Forty to Sixty-Five Feet From the Sandblasting for a Decade. The Sand Arrived Without a Warning About Breathing It.

    Howard Barnett worked for a decade at Mississippi Steel and Iron, forty to sixty-five feet from sandblasting operations, in conditions he and a coworker both called extremely dusty. He developed silicosis. The claim was that the silica sand was defective because it came without adequate warnings about the danger of inhaling it.

    After trial: Affirmed in part and final. Judgment was entered November 28, 2012 for $1,095,000, which includes $500,000 in punitive damages, plus 8 percent post-judgment interest. The Mississippi Court of Appeals affirmed that judgment on August 23, 2016 (No. 2013-CA-01296-COA) but vacated and remanded the separate award of $212,312.50 in attorneys' fees, so that amount is excluded from the figure here. The Mississippi Supreme Court granted certiorari on May 18, 2017 and then dismissed the writ as unnecessary, leaving the Court of Appeals disposition intact. Note that punitive damages are not subject to the noneconomic cap in Miss. Code Ann. 11-1-60, which is why the $500,000 punitive award survived whole. The jury apportioned 35 percent of the fault to Valley.

    Porter & Malouf, P.A.2016 · Hinds County Circuit Court, First Judicial District, MS (affirmed in part, Mississippi Court of Appeals)Read the full story →

All Mississippi verdicts and settlements

12 results, largest first

$4,078,223VerdictCar Accidents

Matthew Feldman, 32, was a passenger being driven back to a work cabin by a co-worker who had been drinking. In heavy rain the driver hydroplaned at about 50 mph and hit a guardrail head-on. The rail went through the engine and into the passenger cab, pinning Feldman against the rear window. His right leg was amputated.

Carroll Bufkin, PLLC2024 · Circuit Court of Newton County, MS (Decatur)Read the full story →
$3,500,000 settlement (Harrison County's share; the jail's medical contractor and the City of Gulfport settled separately for undisclosed sums)SettlementCivil Rights

Jessie Lee Williams Jr., 40, a father of seven, was booked into the Harrison County Adult Detention Center in Gulfport on misdemeanor charges on February 4, 2006. In the booking room Sgt. Ryan Teel and other guards punched and kicked him while he was restrained, Tasered him, pepper-sprayed him through a spit mask, wrapped a soaked sheet over his face and beat him in a restraint chair. He was brain dead by February 6. Teel was sentenced to life. Harrison County settled the family's civil rights suit in July 2007 for $3,500,000.

Michael W. Crosby, Attorney at Law2007 · U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Mississippi, GulfportRead the full story →
$3,400,000 judgment ($2,800,000 economic plus $600,000 noneconomic, Manitowoc's 40 percent share of an $8,500,000 verdict, affirmed)VerdictReduced from $8.5 millionProduct Liability

On June 25, 2014 John Williams Jr., a certified crane operator at the VT Halter Marine shipyard in Pascagoula, was in the cab of a Manitowoc Model 16000 crawler crane during a three-crane lift of a ship's bow when the cranes began pulling apart and his tipped. The 18,000-pound steel counterweights stacked on its rear slid forward and struck the cab, throwing him eight feet head-first onto concrete. He survived, permanently incapacitated. A Gulfport jury found Manitowoc never warned operators that could happen and awarded $8,500,000; after fault was split 50/40/10 the judgment against Manitowoc was $3,400,000, and the Fifth Circuit affirmed in 2018.

Owen, Owen & Smith, PLLC2018 · U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Mississippi, GulfportRead the full story →
$3,400,000 judgment ($2,800,000 economic plus $600,000 noneconomic, Manitowoc's 40 percent share of an $8,500,000 verdict, affirmed)VerdictReduced from $8.5 millionProduct Liability

On June 25, 2014 John Williams Jr., a certified crane operator at the VT Halter Marine shipyard in Pascagoula, was in the cab of a Manitowoc Model 16000 crawler crane during a three-crane lift of a ship's bow when the cranes began pulling apart and his tipped. The 18,000-pound steel counterweights stacked on its rear slid forward and struck the cab, throwing him eight feet head-first onto concrete. He survived, permanently incapacitated. A Gulfport jury found Manitowoc never warned operators that could happen and awarded $8,500,000; after fault was split 50/40/10 the judgment against Manitowoc was $3,400,000, and the Fifth Circuit affirmed in 2018.

Tobias & Comer Law, LLC2018 · U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Mississippi, GulfportRead the full story →
$3,000,000 settlementSettlementCivil Rights

On March 12, 2007 Michael Burnley, 23, was in his cell at the Hinds County jail in Raymond when another prisoner, John Earl Kennedy, jimmied the faulty lock on the door, got in, and repeatedly body-slammed him. Burnley was left paralyzed from mid-chest down. Sheriff Malcolm McMillin acknowledged the cell locks had been faulty since the jail opened in 1994, a fourteen-year-old defect that cost about $20,000 to fix. The county settled his Section 1983 suit on April 21, 2008 for $3,000,000.

Turnage Law Office2008 · U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Mississippi, JacksonRead the full story →
Approximately $2.8 million settlement (gross verdict $4,691,000)SettlementReduced from $4.7 millionMedical Malpractice

Ellen Kelly died after latex exposure during surgery at Baptist Hospital in Jackson. A form from an earlier procedure at the same hospital already recorded her latex allergy. The jury found against the hospital and cleared the physicians, on the reasoning that the nurses and the doctors owed separate duties.

Sweet & Associates, PLLC2011 · Hinds County Circuit Court, First Judicial District, MS (verdict affirmed, Miss. Ct. App.)Read the full story →
$2,781,094.40 (affirmed; $4 million gross verdict before the cap)VerdictReduced from $4 millionCar Accidents

Lisa Learmonth was severely injured in August 2005 when a Sears van driven by a Sears employee collided with her vehicle. A federal jury returned a unanimous general verdict of $4 million without itemizing it, and that single choice set up a fight over Mississippi's damages cap that ran to the Fifth Circuit and the Mississippi Supreme Court.

Hamilton Law Firm, PLLC2013 · U.S. District Court, Southern District of Mississippi, Eastern Division (Meridian)Read the full story →
$2,759,094.32VerdictTruck Accidents

Ashley Newton was driving behind an automobile-hauler trailer on U.S. Highway 49 when its driver drifted across into her lane without signalling. She fractured a cervical vertebra in two places, her hip, her knee, and her tibia and fibula in compound fractures, and needed numerous surgeries.

Blackmon & Blackmon, PLLC2023 · Hinds County Circuit Court, First Judicial District, MS (affirmed; certiorari denied)Read the full story →
$2,750,000 settlement ($2,500,000 from George County plus $250,000 from its insurer, certified as a judgment)SettlementCivil Rights

William Joel Dixon, 28, an insulin-dependent diabetic, was held in the George County Regional Correctional Facility in Lucedale in September 2014. For seven days he got no insulin. The jail nurse, Carmon Sue Brannan, dismissed his worsening condition as methamphetamine withdrawal. He died on September 24, 2014 of diabetic ketoacidosis. Brannan was convicted of manslaughter and sentenced to 15 years. In June 2022 George County agreed to pay his estate, his mother and his children $2,750,000.

Wetzel Law Firm2022 · U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Mississippi, GulfportRead the full story →
$2,000,000 to Michael Keith Howard (a separate $2,000,000 was awarded to Shannon Poole; both affirmed)VerdictPremises Liability

On June 27, 2008 Michael Keith Howard stepped out of his room at the InTown Suites extended-stay motel on the edge of Jackson to walk his dog. As he came back, three men burst through the door, hit him in the face with a handgun, held the gun to his partner Shannon Poole's head, and ransacked the room. Howard needed facial reconstructive surgery. The motel knew loiterers roamed the property, that its fence was in disrepair and that its room locks did not work. A Hinds County jury awarded Howard $2,000,000 and Poole a separate $2,000,000, and the Mississippi Supreme Court affirmed both in 2011.

Ogden & Associates, PLLC2011 · Hinds County Circuit Court, First Judicial District, Jackson MSRead the full story →
$2,000,000 to Shannon Poole (a separate $2,000,000 was awarded to Michael Keith Howard; both affirmed)VerdictPremises Liability

On June 27, 2008 three men burst into the room Shannon Poole shared with her partner Michael Keith Howard at the InTown Suites extended-stay motel on the edge of Jackson. One pistol-whipped Howard and then held the gun to Poole's head; another flipped the mattress with her on it and shoved her into a wall. She was left with contusions, lasting soreness and severe psychological injury. The motel knew loiterers roamed the property, that its fence was in disrepair and that its room locks did not work. A Hinds County jury awarded Poole $2,000,000 and Howard a separate $2,000,000, and the Mississippi Supreme Court affirmed both in 2011.

Ogden & Associates, PLLC2011 · Hinds County Circuit Court, First Judicial District, Jackson MSRead the full story →
$1,095,000 (including $500,000 punitive), affirmedProduct Liability

Howard Barnett worked for a decade at Mississippi Steel and Iron, forty to sixty-five feet from sandblasting operations, in conditions he and a coworker both called extremely dusty. He developed silicosis. The claim was that the silica sand was defective because it came without adequate warnings about the danger of inhaling it.

Porter & Malouf, P.A.2016 · Hinds County Circuit Court, First Judicial District, MS (affirmed in part, Mississippi Court of Appeals)Read the full story →