Top Individual Personal Injury Verdicts and Settlements of 2006
The 10 largest individual personal injury results from 2006, nationwide on record here, ranked by amount: one client's, one family's, or one incident's recovery, never a pooled fund. Each links to the full story, the firm, and the record behind the number.
- $216.8 millionVerdict
$216.8 Million Verdict for Stroke Patient Misdiagnosed as Sinusitis
A Hillsborough County jury awarded $216.8 million to Allan Navarro after an emergency room misdiagnosed his stroke as sinusitis, leaving him permanently paralyzed. It was the largest medical malpractice verdict in Florida history at the time.
After trial: The case settled confidentially in March 2007, before appellate review.
- $44 millionVerdict
$44 Million Verdict for Man Left Quadriplegic by Baltimore Police Officer
William H. Murphy Jr. won a $44 million Baltimore jury verdict after a police officer threw handcuffed Albert Mosley headfirst into a concrete jail cell wall, rendering him a permanent quadriplegic; the city refused to pay and the case ultimately settled for $1 million.
After trial: The $44 million judgment stood. Baltimore declined to indemnify the officer, whom the jury found acted with malice, and the case later settled for $1 million, as former City Solicitor George Nilson confirmed in 2018.
- $18.56 millionVerdict
Chemo Drug Mix-Up Leaves Leukemia Patient Paralyzed, Jury Awards $18.56 Million
A pharmacist three months into her probationary period at a New Jersey hospital let a spinal-toxic chemotherapy drug mix into a leukemia patient's intrathecal dose during what was supposed to be his final treatment, leaving him permanently paralyzed from the waist down. A Middlesex County jury found the pharmacist at fault and held the hospital liable for her conduct, while clearing the oncologist who gave the injections. Jurors awarded the patient $18,564,000, including $17.5 million for pain and suffering. Defense counsel told the New Jersey Law Journal that a high-low agreement entered before trial would reduce what the patient actually recovers; the figure was not reported.
After trial: A pre-trial high-low agreement caps what Weck actually recovers below the jury's $18,564,000 figure. The agreement's terms were not reported, so the amount collected is not public.
Eichen Crutchlow Zaslow, LLP2006 · Superior Court of New Jersey, Law Division, Middlesex CountyRead the full story → - $18 millionVerdict
$3.5 Million Settlement After $18 Million Verdict Over Haldol Death of Idaho Nursing Home Resident
Delbert Hayward, 86, a mechanic, died in February 1995 after nearly a year at Valley Vista Care Center in St. Maries, Idaho, where his family said he was repeatedly given the antipsychotic drug Haldol to control him. After a three-week trial in May 2006, a Benewah County jury returned an $18 million punitive verdict. By November 2006 the case had resolved in a $3.5 million settlement, most of it paid by the home's insurers.
After trial: The $18 million punitive verdict of May 2006 was replaced by a $3.5 million settlement by November 2006, before any appeal. About $3.4 million came from the home's two insurers and about $100,000 from the home.
Eymann Allison Hunter Jones, P.S.2006 · Benewah County District Court, St. Maries, IdahoRead the full story → - $16.5 millionVerdict
Carbon Dioxide for Oxygen: $16.5 Million Federal Verdict Against Tripler Army Medical Center
A federal judge awarded $16.5 million to the family of a newborn who suffered permanent brain damage after an Army pediatrician at Tripler Army Medical Center administered carbon dioxide instead of oxygen for 42 minutes following his birth. It was the largest single personal-injury judgment for an individual in Hawaii history at the time.
Cronin, Fried, Sekiya, Kekina & Fairbanks2006 · U.S. District Court, District of Hawaii (Honolulu)Read the full story → - $14.5 millionVerdictReduced from $106 millionNot collectable
$14.5 Million Judgment Against Kristin Rossum in the Fentanyl Murder of Greg de Villers
A San Diego jury held former county toxicologist Kristin Rossum and San Diego County responsible for the 2000 fentanyl killing of Greg de Villers, awarding his family $106 million in a wrongful death case tried by John Gomez.
After trial: The jury awarded $6 million in compensatory damages and $100 million in punitive damages; the trial judge cut the punitive award to $10 million, and the Court of Appeal in 2007 erased the County's $1.5 million share, leaving $14.5 million against Rossum. She is serving a life sentence and has no assets, and the family has said it does not expect to collect.
- $9.94 millionVerdictOn appeal
Dallas Jury Awards $9.94 Million to McKinney Banker Whose Esophagus Was Perforated by a Hospital Feeding Tube
In May 2006 a Dallas jury voted 11-1 that Medical Center of McKinney, an HCA hospital, was liable after a nasogastric tube perforated the esophagus of patient Tom Ivey following stomach surgery in early 2002. The jury placed the fault on the hospital's nurses and found the surgeon neither negligent nor liable. It awarded Mr. Ivey and his wife, Sandra, $9,944,406. The hospital said it would appeal, and we found no reported appellate decision.
After trial: The hospital said after the verdict that it would appeal. We found no appellate opinion or reported outcome, so we cannot confirm what legally stood or whether the judgment was paid.
- $6.3 millionReduced from $7.5 million
Lake County Jury Finds Anesthesiologist Liable in 12-Year-Old's Death During Surgery at Condell Medical Center
A 12-year-old boy died during surgery to repair a cut at Condell Medical Center in Libertyville in December 1999. A Lake County jury returned a $7.5 million wrongful death verdict against the surgeon and the anesthesiologist in February 2006. After credit for co-defendant settlements, a $6.3 million judgment stood, and the Illinois Appellate Court affirmed it in 2008.
After trial: The $7.5 million verdict was reduced to a $6.3 million judgment by setoffs for the surgeon's $1 million settlement and the hospital's $200,000 settlement. The Illinois Appellate Court, Second District, affirmed that judgment on June 20, 2008, rejecting a Good Samaritan Act defense.
Salvi, Schostok & Pritchard P.C.2006 · Circuit Court of Lake County, Illinois (affirmed, Ill. App. Ct., 2d Dist., No. 2-06-0587, June 20, 2008)Read the full story → - $5.52 millionVerdictReduced from $5.6 millionNot collectable
Jury Awards Family of Hilo Patient Over $5 Million After Surgeon Implants Cut Screwdriver in Spine
A Hawaii County jury in 2006 awarded the family of a 73-year-old patient about $5.6 million after surgeon Robert Ricketson implanted a cut screwdriver shaft in his spine at Hilo Medical Center. The jury put 65 percent of the fault on Ricketson and 35 percent on the hospital for credentialing him, with $3.4 million in punitive damages against Ricketson. The trial judge cut the hospital's share, the appeals court largely upheld that cut while keeping the hospital jointly liable, and the judgment against Ricketson was $5,517,500.
After trial: The trial judge set the hospital's liability at $629,250, and in 2012 the Intermediate Court of Appeals vacated and remanded, keeping the hospital jointly liable and ordering a Medtronic retrial. The judgment against Ricketson, including $3.4 million in punitive damages, is doubtful to be paid because he was uninsured and his whereabouts were uncertain.
Davis Levin Livingston2006 · Circuit Court of the Third Circuit, Hawaii County (Hilo), HawaiiRead the full story → - $5.26 millionReduced from $6.5 million
Federal Judge Awards $5.26 Million to Mother Brain-Damaged After Missed Chiari Malformation at Andrews AFB
After a February 2006 bench trial under the Federal Tort Claims Act, a federal judge in Maryland found that providers at Malcolm Grow Medical Center missed Ruth Lawson's Chiari Type I malformation during her second pregnancy, leaving her permanently and severely brain-damaged. The court entered a $5,264,657.01 judgment in September 2006, after cutting her $1.8 million noneconomic award to Maryland's $590,000 statutory cap.
After trial: The court valued noneconomic damages at $1.8 million and cut them to Maryland's $590,000 cap, so the $5,264,657.01 judgment is the ranked figure. In March 2007 the court denied the government's motions to offset future Tricare benefits or place the future-care award in a reversionary trust.
Stein Mitchell Beato & Missner LLP2006 · U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland, GreenbeltRead the full story →
All 2006 verdicts and settlements
18 results, largest first
A Hillsborough County jury awarded $216.8 million to Allan Navarro after an emergency room misdiagnosed his stroke as sinusitis, leaving him permanently paralyzed. It was the largest medical malpractice verdict in Florida history at the time.
A Philadelphia jury found that Walmart had denied nearly 188,000 Pennsylvania workers paid rest breaks and pay for off-the-clock hours, and the judgment entered on that verdict grew to roughly $188 million.
Thomas Demetrio of Corboy & Demetrio represented seven of the people killed and injured when a suspended work platform fell from the John Hancock Center in 2002, part of a $75 million global settlement reached on the eve of trial.
William H. Murphy Jr. won a $44 million Baltimore jury verdict after a police officer threw handcuffed Albert Mosley headfirst into a concrete jail cell wall, rendering him a permanent quadriplegic; the city refused to pay and the case ultimately settled for $1 million.
A pharmacist three months into her probationary period at a New Jersey hospital let a spinal-toxic chemotherapy drug mix into a leukemia patient's intrathecal dose during what was supposed to be his final treatment, leaving him permanently paralyzed from the waist down. A Middlesex County jury found the pharmacist at fault and held the hospital liable for her conduct, while clearing the oncologist who gave the injections. Jurors awarded the patient $18,564,000, including $17.5 million for pain and suffering. Defense counsel told the New Jersey Law Journal that a high-low agreement entered before trial would reduce what the patient actually recovers; the figure was not reported.
Delbert Hayward, 86, a mechanic, died in February 1995 after nearly a year at Valley Vista Care Center in St. Maries, Idaho, where his family said he was repeatedly given the antipsychotic drug Haldol to control him. After a three-week trial in May 2006, a Benewah County jury returned an $18 million punitive verdict. By November 2006 the case had resolved in a $3.5 million settlement, most of it paid by the home's insurers.
A federal judge awarded $16.5 million to the family of a newborn who suffered permanent brain damage after an Army pediatrician at Tripler Army Medical Center administered carbon dioxide instead of oxygen for 42 minutes following his birth. It was the largest single personal-injury judgment for an individual in Hawaii history at the time.
A San Diego jury held former county toxicologist Kristin Rossum and San Diego County responsible for the 2000 fentanyl killing of Greg de Villers, awarding his family $106 million in a wrongful death case tried by John Gomez.
In May 2006 a Dallas jury voted 11-1 that Medical Center of McKinney, an HCA hospital, was liable after a nasogastric tube perforated the esophagus of patient Tom Ivey following stomach surgery in early 2002. The jury placed the fault on the hospital's nurses and found the surgeon neither negligent nor liable. It awarded Mr. Ivey and his wife, Sandra, $9,944,406. The hospital said it would appeal, and we found no reported appellate decision.
A 12-year-old boy died during surgery to repair a cut at Condell Medical Center in Libertyville in December 1999. A Lake County jury returned a $7.5 million wrongful death verdict against the surgeon and the anesthesiologist in February 2006. After credit for co-defendant settlements, a $6.3 million judgment stood, and the Illinois Appellate Court affirmed it in 2008.
A Hawaii County jury in 2006 awarded the family of a 73-year-old patient about $5.6 million after surgeon Robert Ricketson implanted a cut screwdriver shaft in his spine at Hilo Medical Center. The jury put 65 percent of the fault on Ricketson and 35 percent on the hospital for credentialing him, with $3.4 million in punitive damages against Ricketson. The trial judge cut the hospital's share, the appeals court largely upheld that cut while keeping the hospital jointly liable, and the judgment against Ricketson was $5,517,500.
After a February 2006 bench trial under the Federal Tort Claims Act, a federal judge in Maryland found that providers at Malcolm Grow Medical Center missed Ruth Lawson's Chiari Type I malformation during her second pregnancy, leaving her permanently and severely brain-damaged. The court entered a $5,264,657.01 judgment in September 2006, after cutting her $1.8 million noneconomic award to Maryland's $590,000 statutory cap.
A Shelby County jury found Norfolk Southern 100 percent at fault after veteran conductor Thomas David Jordan was struck by a passing BNSF train while working between dangerously close tracks in South Memphis, awarding $5 million under the Federal Employers' Liability Act. Wettermark Keith co-founder Chris Keith was counsel of record for Jordan, and the Tennessee Court of Appeals affirmed the judgment entered on the verdict in 2009.
A federal court found the U.S. government liable for the 1984 murder of FBI informant John McIntyre after agent John Connolly disclosed his identity to Winter Hill Gang leaders Whitey Bulger and Stephen Flemmi, and the First Circuit affirmed the $3.1 million award in 2008.
A Prince George's County jury found an undercover officer liable for fatally shooting Prince Jones, an unarmed Howard University student stopped in a case of mistaken identity, and awarded his young daughter $2.5 million.
Gerald Barnett, a retired FBI agent from South Carolina, took Vioxx starting in 1999 for chronic neck and back pain and suffered a heart attack in September 2002 at age 58, followed by quintuple bypass surgery. His case was chosen as the second bellwether trial in the federal Vioxx multidistrict litigation, and on August 17, 2006 a New Orleans jury found Merck had negligently failed to warn his doctors of the drug's risks and had concealed information about those risks, awarding him $50 million in compensatory damages and $1 million in punitive damages. The trial judge found the compensatory award excessive and ordered a new trial unless Barnett accepted a reduced award; Barnett accepted a remittitur of $1.6 million on June 20, 2007, and judgment was entered in that amount on June 28, 2007. Merck reported that it appealed that judgment, and no decision resolving the appeal has been published.
A Coles County, Illinois jury awarded Katherine Adams $561,389.90 against Sarah Bush Lincoln Health Center and surgeon Dr. Kellie Jones-Monahan. During a routine laparoscopic gallbladder removal on November 15, 2002, the surgeon divided Adams's common bile duct, and she needed an ambulance transfer to a St. Louis hospital and a reconstructive operation. At trial the surgeon admitted that the common bile duct had been mistakenly dissected. The Illinois Appellate Court, Fourth District, affirmed the verdict in January 2007.
A pregnant passenger was hurt in a June 2005 car crash and delivered her son by emergency cesarean section at 20 to 22 weeks. He lived one hour and six minutes. A Denver jury awarded $101,500 for his death and put half the fault on the driver she was riding with, and judgment against that driver came to $64,948.61 with costs and interest. The Colorado Court of Appeals affirmed in 2008, holding that a wrongful death claim exists for a child born alive before viability.
Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Each case is unique and depends on its own facts.